Re:Why Minds Are Not Like Computers (2009)
by danieltillett on Thursday March 27, 2014 @06:26AM
(#7479491)
I would have thought it was obvious that minds are not like computers, the really interesting question is are minds Turing machines?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why Minds Are Not Like Computers (2009)
by TonyNib on Thursday March 27, 2014 @06:44AM
(#7479531)
How would you go about proving that?
Also, is this something that has to be resolved before big advancements can be made in strong AI?
Re:Why Minds Are Not Like Computers (2009)
by danieltillett on Thursday March 27, 2014 @07:26AM
(#7479659)
It is not provable and it doesn't matter. It really doesn't matter if an AI is really thinking or not - all that matters is can it simulate thinking to a level that we can't tell the difference.
Given that you can emulate a turing machine in your mind, I'd assume that it is more than a Turing machine.
Re:Why Minds Are Not Like Computers (2009)
by Sharlin on Thursday March 27, 2014 @07:57AM
(#7479770)
It is not proven that a human mind can emulate all Turing machines (given an arbitrary amount of external storage). All physical computers are "just" finite state machines (because they don't have unbounded storage); you can emulate a subset of Turing machines using an FSM just fine even though a TM is strictly more powerful than an FSM.
Re:Why Minds Are Not Like Computers (2009)
by bencollier49 on Thursday March 27, 2014 @06:58AM
(#7479578)
But no infinite tape. I can't remember if that's essential to the definition of a Turing machine?
Re:Why Minds Are Not Like Computers (2009)
by Sharlin on Thursday March 27, 2014 @07:55AM
(#7479762)
Obviously no physical machine can have an actual unbounded tape (note that unbounded is not the same as infinite!) The interesting question is whether the brain is Turing-equivalent if given a notebook with an unlimited number of pages to keep track of the program state.
Re:Why Minds Are Not Like Computers (2009)
by eli_gottlieb on Thursday March 27, 2014 @07:18AM
(#7479632)
Any Universal Turing Machine can emulate any other Turing machine. That's not interesting. What would be interesting would be if human minds could solve the Halting Problem.
Re:Why Minds Are Not Like Computers (2009)
by danieltillett on Thursday March 27, 2014 @07:27AM
(#7479671)
This would prove that humans are not Turing machines - so far no human has solved this.
Re:Why Minds Are Not Like Computers (2009)
by danieltillett on Thursday March 27, 2014 @07:20AM
(#7479642)
I don't think this is actually known.