News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by quakkels on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:10PM (#7468169)
I can't tell if this is good or bad. But, does it strike anyone else as odd that the IRS ignores that bitcoin _is_ actually currency? Can they even declare it to be property when the reality is that it is currency?
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by dragonwriter on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:20PM (#7468241)
> But, does it strike anyone else as odd that the IRS ignores that bitcoin _is_ actually currency? Can they even declare it to be property when the reality is that it is currency?

"Property" is a statement about a legal relationship between a person and some (tangible or intangible) thing.

"Currency" is a statement about an attribute of a thing idnependent of its legal relationship to any person.

Whether a thing is "currency" and whether it is someone's "property" are orthogonal concerns. It can be either, both, or neither. The fact that it is one does not prevent it from being the other.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by bertil on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:38PM (#7468368)
As I understand it, the main difference is that, if it were currency, you’d need to go though a lot of regulation to process it, keep it and change it with dollars.

I doubt the IRS can influence SEC and the Financial commission into the finer points of Legal tender. What they say is: no matter that, these things are like stock, and we feel the right to tax your profits on trading them.

Sounds reasonable to me.

Put otherwise: it sounds like when a lawyer (or The Dude) says that you are “an asshole”. Most lawyers don’t really have the moral standing to accuse anyone of that, but what they are saying is: my qualifications are telling you what is legal and what isn’t, and this unsavory action isn’t illegal. IRS is saying: BitCoins are not just to pay for your groceries, they are a way to store and accrue value; they have no standing on how convenient they are or should be to buy groceries.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by URSpider94 on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @11:53PM (#7471475)
Collectible antique coins are also currency -- a buffalo nickel is still legal tender, but you'd be a fool to use it in a bubble gum vending machine. Nonetheless, the IRS treats them as property, for purposes of taxation.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by lutusp on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:17PM (#7468214)
> Can they even declare it to be property when the reality is that it is currency?

It seems you're overlooking the possibility that it may be both.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by saraid216 on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:21PM (#7468249)
What would you say the difference between property and currency is?
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by nullz on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:25PM (#7468288)
define 'reality'