However, I think they are going about this all wrong, their not going to stop people making similar cups and will just create negative impressions with consumers - first time a valid Keurig cup that a customer purchased fails the test and you'll have a very angry customer.
I hear this argument a lot, but I just don't buy it. If anything, the customer will be upset with the manufacturer of the coffee cup. But as is, all of Keurig's cups are clearly marked, and I suspect that the vast majority of customers will just continue to buy those (and therefore be totally unaffected by this change).
Not sure if they still do, but at one point Nescafé/Nespresso started adding notches to pods (and machines) which would pierce through un-notched "compatible" pods and ruin them.
Of course that "only" invalidated the current stock for new machines, it'd still work on old machines and was simple enough to reverse-"engineer".
> All that would be required is a patented physical feature that can't easily be worked around. […] They simply threaten to sue anyone who makes a compatible charger for patent infringement. I don't see why this would be different.
I'm pretty sure Keurig's moving to an RM system because their k-cups patents are expired (the basic ones expired a few years ago, I guess those for "upgraded" k-cups are now dead) in the first place.
If they can keep it technically illegal to sell a compatible pod in North America and Europe, they've probably pretty well captured the available profit.
All that would be required is a patented physical feature that can't easily be worked around. After all, they probably don't care about someone 3D printing a compatible reusable pod at home. Rather, they want a cut of any mass-market pods that work with their machine.
Apple, for instance, has effectively prevented anyone from making MagSafe-compatible chargers without using any sort of DRM. They simply threaten to sue anyone who makes a compatible charger for patent infringement. I don't see why this would be different.