Re:Ask HN: where'd my ability to downvote go?
by Semiapies on Thursday August 06, 2009 @11:25AM
(#745661)
This keeps coming up, and people keep linking to pg's post on saying that's exactly the intent of down-voting.
Re:Ask HN: where'd my ability to downvote go?
by cema on Thursday August 06, 2009 @12:17PM
(#745771)
Well, pg controls it to a large extent, but not 100%.
Re:Ask HN: where'd my ability to downvote go?
by Semiapies on Thursday August 06, 2009 @09:25PM
(#746820)
It's his site. If he says downvoting is appropriate for expressing disagreement, then there's no basis for saying that isn't "what down votes are for".
Re:Ask HN: where'd my ability to downvote go?
by cema on Wednesday August 12, 2009 @06:54PM
(#759476)
He has built the site, and people are building the news forum. It appears (or perhaps "it emerges") that what they are using the voting system for is close to his vision but not 100%. Of course he can still guide it, but the crowd works its ways.
Re:Ask HN: where'd my ability to downvote go?
by smithjchris on Thursday August 06, 2009 @11:50AM
(#745715)
Particularly when you go "against the grain" on here. If I dare say anything negative about LISP, Emacs, the environment or business mentality, I get shot down straight away.
Seriously, while down votes are needed sometimes, I think they are overused. I often see a legitimate comment voted down because someone apparently disagrees with its contents. This is not what down votes are for.