Now, an unfair law is exposed as unfair because all will suffer.
Seems to me that with zero tolerance policies where there is no individual interpretation of the intent of the rule, too many people are unjustly punished for honest mistakes (e.g., forgetting about having a knife in their vehicle at school) or attempts to do well by someone else (e.g., taking a knife away from someone that was trying to hurt themselves).
Policemen are not judges, nor should they ever be. The problem with Zero Tolerance is that the judges are overly strict. We want policemen to enforce the letter. We want judges to consider the spirit of the law, and interpret it appropriately. Policemen lack the knowledge of the law and lack the time to make these decisions in a rational manner. They are forced to rely on poor heuristics. There is less immediacy to a judge's decision.
So, yes, I think it fair that someone who forgets he has a knife in his car is removed from class pending an evaluation of the situation (with this taking place in a reasonable amount of time). Then I believe it only fair if the evaluation determines that if it was truly accidental, then he return.
It's about "punishing" everyone the same to the letter of the law/rule in question. Often without due process and common sense.
Things would be better between the public and the police if they did treat everyone the same, but that's not zero tolerance policy.
If laws produce significant social distress to a large number of people, then the law is more likely to be changed.
Whereas if it's only ever enforced against black people, or people the policeman has decided to screw for whatever reason, then it could go on forever.
#
If you think of police action as being analogous to pain, then it's not clear that less pain is always the best thing for society in the long run.