News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The One True Text Editor by jrockway on Thursday August 06, 2009 @09:18AM (#745371)
Wow, a lot of unsubstantiated "facts" to justify your personal preference. Let me guess, the color green is better than the color orange because your eyes are more sensitive to green? After all, it's your favorite right?

Anyway, I disagree on your comments about integration. Vim, irssi, mutt, and ddd all use separate keybinding semantics. Switch programs, and everything you know about using your software is thrown out the window -- now you are doing something totally new. Repeat several times a day.

Integration affords the possibilities for greater reuse. I wrote an extension for managing "projects". Thanks to eshell, I can easily manage my projects from the command-line now, not just when I am editing files in emacs. (And, there are no hacks involved; no forking a process every time I want my editor to open another file in the project, as would be required if you wanted to do this with vi and bash.)

It's a collection of mediocre tools rather than one excellent tool.

Maybe the stuff you write is...

Re:The One True Text Editor by smithjchris on Thursday August 06, 2009 @11:45AM (#745706)
How can it be a fact if it's not substantiated?

It's all down to opinion, which I chose to share. Now some replies which are all my opinion again.

a) All my keybindings are approximately vim-like. Mutt uses vim as an editor. I use the mouse for ddd (nail me to a cross for my sins). irssi mainly involves: type stuff, whack enter.

b) Blue is my favourite colour (particularly oceandeep.vim).

c) Revelation: I avoid "project management" tools. That is what the filesystem and the related tools are for.

d) Regarding forking, UNIX was designed to be small utilities working together to build systems greater than the sum of it's parts, not one monolithic environment. Otherwise they wouldn't have added the fork() syscall would they? Hence, in vim, whack bang (!) and type a shell command. Pipe stuff in, get stuff out.

e) I admit, my writing style is terrible.

..zzZZ