We think most users are searching for stories, but maybe we're wrong. Btw, we're currently working on an analytics feature that process all queries performed on an Algolia account. I'll use it to count the number of queries performed on comments/stories/all. Data-driven isn't it? ;)
Just out of curiosity, why is the default for search "story" instead of "all"? I believe that hnsearch.com's default was "all".