Re:Ask HN: What is your favorite board game and why?
by jibiki on Thursday August 06, 2009 @12:50AM
(#744839)
> This is an advantage that Go has over Chess, where removing pieces would just be silly.
It used to be rather popular, actually, to play at pawn-and-move odds. If you search through old games, you'll eventually come across one where black starts without an f pawn.
There's also a famous Capablanca game where a young Capablanca is given a queen by his opponent (he wins, of course.)
I'd say the two biggest problems with chess are:
1. Too many draws.
2. First move has too big an advantage.
Neither of these is a problem in Go (draws are extremely rare or even impossible in many rule sets, and the second player is now given enough points that the game is almost even.)
It used to be rather popular, actually, to play at pawn-and-move odds. If you search through old games, you'll eventually come across one where black starts without an f pawn.
There's also a famous Capablanca game where a young Capablanca is given a queen by his opponent (he wins, of course.)
I'd say the two biggest problems with chess are:
1. Too many draws.
2. First move has too big an advantage.
Neither of these is a problem in Go (draws are extremely rare or even impossible in many rule sets, and the second player is now given enough points that the game is almost even.)
I like both games a lot. Arimaa is fun too.