News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Poll: The new HN comment system – agree, disagree, or wai... by jonesetc on Saturday March 22, 2014 @12:38AM (#7447609)
I meant it to go along with the rest of the paragraph. I think you'll see people turn around at the door with this policy. I would have.
Re:Poll: The new HN comment system – agree, disagree, or wai... by jfoster on Saturday March 22, 2014 @01:11AM (#7447763)
That's certainly a possibility. It would show up in HN's metrics. (perhaps not visible to you and I, though)

On the other hand, you might also see more people coming in the door. What if this makes conversation on HN so much better that more people want to get involved?

The one thing that is certain with the new system is that if your comments are abusive, they will probably not get endorsed. Perhaps at first they will (protesting 1k+ karma users) but eventually anyone who is endorsing poor quality comments would likely lose the ability to endorse.

At a minimum, I think this a really interesting experiment.

Re:Poll: The new HN comment system – agree, disagree, or wai... by tripzilch on Sunday March 23, 2014 @03:52PM (#7454796)
> protesting 1k+ karma users

well, I'm going to voice my concerns and complain about it, but I'm not going to sabotage the system out of spite. that's childish.

> but eventually anyone who is endorsing poor quality comments would likely lose the ability to endorse.

If that happens it'll be because some invisible moderator has a different idea about "quality comments" than I do.

If it happens, I will lose the ability over endorsing puns.