News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by pktgen on Friday March 21, 2014 @07:07PM (#7445563)
Not defending MS at all but what is the alternative for them? What people want is the judicial oversight. But can Microsoft really go to a court and say "hey judge, we're Microsoft, we want a warrant for Microsoft to provide this"?
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by crygin on Friday March 21, 2014 @07:39PM (#7445709)
Agreed -- based on MS's statement they went through a fairly rigorous internal procedure (of course, they could be lying, but it seems fairly unlikely particularly given the regulatory attention MS generally has on it). I don't fully understand what people think they "should" have done to access the emails -- waste a court's time on a meaningless judgement?
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by chris_mahan on Friday March 21, 2014 @07:59PM (#7445831)
They should have called the FBI, the FBI would have requested a warrant, the Judge would have approved the warrant, and the FBI would have accessed the information in the user's account.

That would have been the correct way to do it.

Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by andrewfong on Friday March 21, 2014 @08:20PM (#7446018)
That doesn't provide a remedy when you only want to launch a civil investigation, not a criminal one. And given how frequently the criminal process is abused to go after relatively minor crimes (e.g. Aaron Swartz), this is probably something we shouldn't encourage.
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by chris_mahan on Saturday March 22, 2014 @03:49PM (#7450561)
Oh, and it's better this way?
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by techsupporter on Friday March 21, 2014 @10:07PM (#7446813)
I disagree. Having this person criminally charged for violating a civil contract (the non-disclosure contract with his now-former employer) is a bad idea. The FBI, or even the City of Redmond Police Department, will require that there be at least the probability of a crime having been committed before they'll go in front of a judge.
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by mirkules on Saturday March 22, 2014 @04:41AM (#7448310)
However, "the complaint alleges that Kibkalo committed criminal trade secret theft", keyword being "criminal". I believe the crime in question is the following federal crime: http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/granule/USCODE-2011-title18/USCODE-...

Whether or not we agree with the law is a separate matter from whether or not a crime was committed -- which they had reasonable suspicion to believe it was. Therefore, they should have gone in front of a judge for a warrant.

Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by kenjackson on Friday March 21, 2014 @09:05PM (#7446366)
I'd think wed want to minimize how often the FBI is combing through data. I'd rather MS pull up an email than the FBI get more free access to data.
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by gkoz on Saturday March 22, 2014 @05:19AM (#7448399)
Isn't a search with a warrant the opposite of free access?
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by pktgen on Friday March 21, 2014 @08:06PM (#7445887)
I've upvoted you because this seems like what they should have done. I didn't think about the criminal aspect.
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by chris_mahan on Saturday March 22, 2014 @03:48PM (#7450552)
Well, because if it wasn't a crime, then they definitely shouldn't have trawling around on his personal hotmail account.
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by mcintyre1994 on Friday March 21, 2014 @09:02PM (#7446346)
It's far too idealist to be realistic, but they shouldn't be able to use that information for their own civil inquiry. If gmail or pgp were used they wouldn't have access to it, it being a Microsoft account shouldn't make its contents available to them for a private investigation. Of course it does and probably always will because they have lots of lawyers and terms of service, but I just disagree with them being able to.

I agree that if they have to do this investigation (and really they're the ones that will ultimately decide that) they shouldn't get anyone else involved - especially the criminal justice system.

I think what I'm trying to get at is that the conversation is turning here toward just how should Microsoft access the data they want, when it should be whether they should be able to at all. I don't like the idea that it's a given that they can take that information, and that's what should change here.

Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by PythonicAlpha on Friday March 21, 2014 @07:42PM (#7445724)
No, not waste!

When you act rightfully, it is never wasting time of the legal system!

Because I can do something (without asking anybody else) it needs not to be right!

Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by ewoodrich on Friday March 21, 2014 @07:48PM (#7445753)
>When you act rightfully, it is never wasting time of the legal system!

In this case, it really would be a waste of time. Microsoft wouldn't be seeking a subpoena, nor are they a government seeking a warrant. Microsoft would just be asking the court for permission to do something the court cannot grant.

There's no legal question, unless say, someone were to sue Microsoft for accessing their data.

Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by PythonicAlpha on Friday March 21, 2014 @08:02PM (#7445857)
I am not familiar with the US law system, but in our country it would be normal, that for example my landlord has to go to court before he can search my house, even when he is the owner. And the warrant is not against the landlord, but against me.

So I disagree with your statement, at least in my country it would be not wasting anything ... but DOING THE RIGHT THING!

And I would really wonder, if in the US the landlord could just search your house, because he thinks that you might have stolen something of him -- with the argument, that he does not want to "waste anybodies time"!

Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by URSpider94 on Friday March 21, 2014 @08:24PM (#7446057)
I think the problem is that we have extensive precedent in the USA that warrants to search cloud data are properly presented to the cloud hosting provider, NOT the "owner" of the data -- in fact, the data owner is often prohibited from even knowing that the process is taking place.

Others have pointed out that this is a clear way in which cloud storage is fundamentally different from local storage, which one might not expect -- being able to be secure in one's papers, a fundamental right in the US, only pertains if the papers are physically located on your person or property.

I'm overextending here, but I think the physical analogy applies as well -- if the police want to search a rented storage locker, the search warrant is served to the storage company, not the lessee of the locker.

Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by PythonicAlpha on Friday March 21, 2014 @10:29PM (#7446959)
If in the US information is only secure, if in your own possession (not any trustee or similar), than cloud storage and any online service of vital documents is just impossible in the US.

If this is the case: I don't think, that many companies are aware of this. But that would render the worth of online services to void for many companies.

Or are we living in a world of morons?

Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by jasonlotito on Friday March 21, 2014 @11:00PM (#7447126)
sigh

If you have information you want to keep private or secure, it's your responsibility to ensure that it private or secure. This means understanding the agreements you make when you store said data in certain locations.

> I don't think, that many companies are aware of this.

No, many companies are in fact aware of this. This is the reason there providers that do provide increased security and oversight as far as data access goes. Apple, Google, and Microsoft just happen to provide free email services that aren't that secure if you violate their T&C.

> than cloud storage and any online service of vital documents is just impossible in the US.

Yeah, if you think using a cloud service outside the US immediately makes you immune to these problems, you are the one who isn't aware of the situation.

Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by PythonicAlpha on Saturday March 22, 2014 @12:07AM (#7447478)
> Yeah, if you think using a cloud service outside the US immediately makes you immune to these problems, you are the one who isn't aware of the situation.

If you read my statements carefully, I did not say that. But in my country there are different laws and I know that many cloud service providers do not have privacy holes as Hotmail has in their legal statements.

I also said, that I don't know how the law in the US is, but some statements here made the impression, that companies like MS could just do what they want.

Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by sytelus on Friday March 21, 2014 @09:17PM (#7446459)
You can't be serious. Microsoft could have filed complaint against employee with law enforcement agency who then would have received warrant to search any properties that law enforcement agency deemed as required.

Key here is that Microsoft is not searching itself. Content of the email account does not belong to Microsoft, it belongs to the user. To search it Microsoft needs explicit permission of user or law enforcement agency.

Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by e12e on Saturday March 22, 2014 @12:28AM (#7447562)
Indeed. Consider this: you are a budding new software engineer, and you've used gmail since it came out. Now you start work at google. And now, google is entitled to search through your email? (Replace outlook.com/hotmail and microsoft, or y! mail and yahoo! etc)
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by PythonicAlpha on Friday March 21, 2014 @07:40PM (#7445713)
A bank also has no right to search a locker that you have rented from them. The bank has to have a warrant against you to search it.
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by cookingrobot on Friday March 21, 2014 @07:49PM (#7445760)
And a landlord has no right to come into your apartment without warning, even if they think you stole something from them.
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by res0nat0r on Friday March 21, 2014 @07:53PM (#7445795)
Except for the T&C you signed with Hotmail when you signed up to explicitly allow them to go through your email.

If you are actually stupid enough to leak trade secrets for Microsoft's premiere product, while using Hotmail to do it, well you really deserve what you get.

Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by PythonicAlpha on Friday March 21, 2014 @07:58PM (#7445823)
I don't know, how the situation in the US is, but in my country, if a landlord would add a statement in the rental agreement, that he can search your home, such a statement would be void from the beginning! Because you can't break or bend the law just by adding a statement in a contract in my country.
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by andrewfong on Friday March 21, 2014 @08:34PM (#7446131)
U.S. laws usually permits landlord inspections so long as they provide notice.
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by dippyskoodlez on Friday March 21, 2014 @09:17PM (#7446462)
That is quite different from the current scenario, and could be called a "warrant".

verb 1. justify or necessitate (a certain course of action).

Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by bryan_rasmussen on Saturday March 22, 2014 @02:13AM (#7447964)
I agree with the stupidity on evidence, but Microsoft's taking advantage of that stupidity of course underlines that they will read your email if they think it is to their advantage to do so and can make a legally satisfactory argument.
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by sliverstorm on Friday March 21, 2014 @07:15PM (#7445598)
Alright Microsoft, your days on the run are over. We, Microsoft, have gotten a subpoena against you. Now cough up that data, us. I mean you.
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by glimcat on Friday March 21, 2014 @07:37PM (#7445700)
Ideally, I'd like to see a situation where you (1) have a contract protecting user data which is reasonably enforceable given the power dynamics which exist between the two parties, and (2) it's required for a judge to arbitrate whether a given situation provides justification to breach that contract.

Where "judge" is proxy for a nominally impartial third party who nominally has the experience to make an informed decision which reasonably protects the interests of both parties, the public interest, and our stated commitments to civil liberties. And we already make routine use of judges for this function in cases where the data or other artifacts are not possessed by the party who wants extraordinary permission to access them.

Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by mindslight on Saturday March 22, 2014 @12:11PM (#7449587)
Microsoft's actions in this case are pretty predictable, and the fact that this is a "story" at all just highlights the lowest common denominator news cycle (or alternatively the out of touch entitlement of webmail users).

But just think if they had filed a civil suit and gone to court for discovery of information that they had possession of but conceivably not the right to - they could have created a nice legal precedent and ended up being lauded by the EFF!

Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by duaneb on Friday March 21, 2014 @07:44PM (#7445732)
> But can Microsoft really go to a court and say "hey judge, we're Microsoft, we want a warrant for Microsoft to provide this"?

Yes. They want people to use their products, don't they? I'm not going to spend money on a product that gives me zero assurance that I have control of my information.

Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by kvb on Friday March 21, 2014 @09:21PM (#7446485)
Can you cite any precedent where a court has agreed to hear such an argument? This is not a rhetorical question - I'm genuinely curious whether civil procedure allows it. As a non-lawyer (and MSFT employee) who is interested in the law, the closest thing I can think of is a motion for declaratory judgment, but even there I think you need an actual case or controversy before the judge will hear arguments.
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by lawnchair_larry on Saturday March 22, 2014 @01:53PM (#7450077)
I think they should just leave their users property alone, and act like a dumb conduit without the ability to inspect. Find other ways to solve the problem. Do what they would do if they were not in the convenient position of being the email host.
Re:Microsoft Says: Come Back with a Warrant, Unless You’re M... by andrewfong on Saturday March 22, 2014 @02:25PM (#7450201)
You missed that "what they would do if they were not in the convenient position of being the email host" is subpoena the email host. Unfortunately, you can't really subpoena yourself. Nor is it clear that they could subpoena the user here and compel the user to give information to Microsoft that Microsoft already has.

The EFF suggests getting the FBI involved and having them serve a court-approved warrant, but that doesn't work if you want to keep this a purely civil process and not involve the police (and given recent abuse of police powers for relatively minor crimes, getting the FBI involved is probably not something to be categorically encouraged).