News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by gautamnarula on Friday March 21, 2014 @06:57PM (#7445507)
Sam Harris, a neuroscientist and philosopher, wrote an interesting post on Islamophobia and how he believes it doesn't actually exist, at least not in the framework that we normally consider phobias: http://www.samharris.org/site/full_text/response-to-controve...

The relevant part:

The meaning of “Islamophobia” is not at all like the meanings of those other terms. It is simply not easy to differentiate prejudice against Muslims from ordinary racism and xenophobia directed at Arabs, Pakistanis, Somalis, and other people who happen to be Muslim. Of course, there is no question that such bigotry exists, and it is as odious as Greenwald believes. But inventing a new term does not give us license to say that there is a new form of hatred in the world. How does the term “anti-Semitism” differ? Well, we have a 2000-year-old tradition of religiously inspired hatred against Jews, conceived as a distinct race of people, both by those who hate them and by Jews themselves. Anti-Semitism is, therefore, a specific form of racism that, as everyone knows, has taken many terrible turns over the years (and is now especially prevalent among Muslims, for reasons that can be explicitly traced not merely to recent conflicts over land in the Middle East, but to the doctrine of Islam). “Sexism,” generally speaking, is a bias against women, not because of any doctrines they might espouse, but because they were born without a Y chromosome. The meanings of these terms are clear, and each names a form of hatred and exclusion directed at people, as people, not because of their behavior or beliefs, but because of the mere circumstances of their birth.

Islamophobia is something else entirely. It is, Greenwald tells us in his three points, an “irrational” and “disproportionate” and “unjustified” focus on Muslims. But the only way that Muslims can reasonably be said to exist as a group is in terms of their adherence to the doctrine of Islam. There is no race of Muslims. They are not united by any physical traits or a diaspora. Unlike Judaism, Islam is a vast, missionary faith. The only thing that defines the class of All Muslims—and the only thing that could make this group the possible target of anyone’s “irrational” fear, “disproportionate” focus, or “unjustified” criticism—is their adherence to a set of beliefs and the behaviors that these beliefs inspire.

And, unlike a person’s racial characteristics or gender, beliefs can be argued for, tested, criticized, and changed. In fact, wherever the norms of rational conversation are allowed to do their work, beliefs must earn respect. More important, beliefs are claims about reality and about how human beings should live within it—so they necessarily lead to behavior, and to values, laws, and public institutions that affect the lives of all people, whether they share these beliefs or not. Beliefs end marriages and start wars.

So “Islamophobia” must be—it really can only be—an irrational, disproportionate, and unjustified fear of certain people, regardless of their ethnicity or any other accidental trait, because of what they believe and to the degree to which they believe it. Thus the relevant question to ask is whether a special concern about people who are deeply committed to the actual doctrines of Islam, in the aftermath of September 11th, 2001, is irrational, disproportionate, and unjustified.

Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by tunesmith on Friday March 21, 2014 @07:18PM (#7445613)
I've never ready anything by Sam Harris that I've considered to be rational and well-reasoned. The guy's whole schtick seems to be making arguments that are valid but unsound. Here his premise is "But the only way that Muslims can reasonably be said to exist as a group is in terms of their adherence to the doctrine of Islam," which is completely false. He implies that anyone who practices Islam is "deeply committed to the actual doctrines" as practiced by the hijackers, which is false. He's implying that people who practice Islamophobia are targeting people by their beliefs, when in reality they will target them by their headwear (see the various crimes against Sikhs, one of the gosh-darn nicest religions in the world). Every time I read something by Harris my blood boils a bit because of how insidious his pseudo-logic is.
Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by mpweiher on Saturday March 22, 2014 @09:38AM (#7448989)
I actually knew Sam when he was a sophomore in college, and his writings strike me as an almost perfect illustration of the term "sophomoric": smart, overconfident, but at the same time immature and lacking in depth and perspective.

His arguments for arming himself smack of complete ignorance of the concept of the monopoly of physical violence[1], and without accounting for those theories (and their practical application in modern states), the whole argument is just vapid.

[1] http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gewaltmonopol_des_Staates http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly_on_violence

Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by ivanca on Saturday March 22, 2014 @04:37AM (#7448303)
>that people who practice Islamophobia are targeting people by their beliefs, when in reality they will target them by their headwear

Are you proposing that they should read minds? As far as I know that's not possible so this statement is preposterous, of course they are going to target by the headgear/skin-color, is the only way they can determine who is Islamic and who is not; being bad at it is a different matter.

Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by MarkTee on Saturday March 22, 2014 @05:33AM (#7448429)
Reread the comment you're replying to; that's exactly what he's saying.
Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by arbitrarywords on Saturday March 22, 2014 @02:03AM (#7447934)
If Islam <-> Muslim is completely false, curious as to how you would define the term?
Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by tunesmith on Saturday March 22, 2014 @03:25AM (#7448149)
That improperly restates my rebuttal. I'm not saying that Islam is never Muslim or vice versa. He's making the forall statement, not me. I'm saying that it's completely false that "The only way that Muslims can reasonably be said to exist as a group is in terms of their adherence to the doctrine of Islam". Trivially refuted since he's making a ∀ statement. You only have to find a ∃ to refute it. Google "cultural muslim", etc.
Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by arbitrarywords on Saturday March 22, 2014 @05:07AM (#7448370)
Well the impression I get is the idea of a "cultural" muslim is contested from both within and without the muslim community so I don't think it's quite that clear cut. Who gets to own the labels seems to always be a political battle. You could argue that it is only "reasonable" to use the label for those who hold the beliefs.
Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by tunesmith on Saturday March 22, 2014 @02:49PM (#7450307)
I'm not really sure if there's a term for the problem with this, but "moral hazard" may apply. If a determination is made to exclude all "cultural muslims" from the definition of muslim, then that determination is probably made by someone who is not a "cultural muslim", and the effects might really suck for the cultural muslims.
Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by MarkTee on Saturday March 22, 2014 @05:35AM (#7448433)
No true Scotsman

How do you decide who owns the "right" beliefs? By that logic, who can we consider to be a Christian?

Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by lotharbot on Saturday March 22, 2014 @10:04AM (#7449095)
"No true Scotsman" is only a fallacy when one uses irrelevant criteria to exclude people from a group.

It's not NtS to point out that James "Scotty" Doohan wasn't Scottish (he was a Canadian of Irish descent.) Nor is it NtS to point out that certain people don't hold various relevant defining characteristics and therefore to claim that they don't count as being in a particular category. Of course, that exclusion is contextual -- it can apply to a particular use of a label without applying to all uses of it.

Note that I disagree with Sam Harris overall. His claim is that the only way Muslims can be reasonably said to exist is his definition; I would argue that one way Muslims can be said to exist is his definition. I would further argue that some people who use other definitions of Islam have irrational/unjustified/disproportionate fear, and can therefore be said to be Islamophobic.

Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by dragonwriter on Friday March 21, 2014 @07:04PM (#7445542)
Not at all to endorse Harris's particular view (EDIT: on which tunesmith's comment that is a sibling of this one sums up my position quite well), but much of the anti-group feelings that we label X-phobia aren't really phobias (either in the clinical sense, or necessarily even in the simple sense of "fear", and much of what is labelled "misogyny" isn't really hate.) In both cases, its a way to ascribe a dismissive blanket explanation to discrimination (from whatever motivation) that the speaker disagrees with. Its probably true that some discrimination against muslims is fear, and some against women is hate, but the use of the blanket terms "Islamophobia" or "misogyny" for that discrimination is a way to assert that it is invalid, slap a neat explanation on it, and dismiss it all in a neat package that resists discussion.
Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by ucarion on Friday March 21, 2014 @07:05PM (#7445550)
I totally agree with you, and I think everyone commenting on this thread should stop and read Sam Harris's "Letter to a Christian Nation". It pretty much covers all the questions being asked here.