First, I don't think that corporations are nothing but parasites, and said as much in the article. I did say that finance was parasitical. That was probably too strong. Allocation of capital is a useful function; the problem is that the allocators are helping themselves to a far larger cut of the proceedings than the value they produce (and I don't particularly want to argue that here, just wanted to clarify what I meant).
Second, the more central point about whether the Singularity Institute types are wasting their time and should refocus their thinking. It is true that not many people are thinking about the effects of superhuman AIs, and there's no harm and possibly some good in a few smart weirdos focusing on that, especially since corporations have been around and critiqued for so long.
However, we are so far away from producing anything remotely close to that level of AI, that I fear their work is ungrounded. It strikes me as fun quasi-SF rather than serious engineering.
But I take believe they are seriously interested in world improvement, so my suggestion to them in their work on "benevolent goal architectures" is to study how existing goal architectures work, that is to look at existing economic and social systems where disparate individual goals are coordinated into cooperative or conflicting action, and how the results are related to human goals and human flourishing.
For my part, I am in the process of trying to understand their friendly AI work better so I critique it from a more informed standpoint.
At what point would you allow research to go forth? And you know, there's a lot of work that can be done which is not 'directly coding an AI'.
> But I take believe they are seriously interested in world improvement, so my suggestion to them in their work on "benevolent goal architectures" is to study how existing goal architectures work, that is to look at existing economic and social systems where disparate individual goals are coordinated into cooperative or conflicting action, and how the results are related to human goals and human flourishing.
But why would one expect any of that to transfer to AI? What do the internal dynamics of a Board of Directors have to do with, say, the Code Red worm? What lessons can we extract from 501(c)3 nonprofits which will tell us anything about deep-learning-based architectures? Do CEO salaries really inform our understanding of Moore's Law? Or can study of Congressional lobbying seriously help us better understand progress on brain scanning and connectomes? Do Marxian dialectics truly help us improve forecasts for when feasible investments in neuromorphic chips will match human brains?
The closer I look at corporations and modern economies, the more worthless they seem for understanding the possibilities of AI, much less engineering safe or powerful ones. Modern economies are based on large assemblages of human brains, acculturated in very specific ways (remember Adam Smith's other major work: _The Theory of Moral Sentiments_), which are limited in many ways, and which are fragile and nonrobust: consider psychopathy, or consider economic's focus on 'institutions'. Why do some economies explode like South Korea, and others go nowhere at all? Even with millennia of human history and almost identical genomes and brains, outcomes are staggeringly different. (You complain about corporations; well, how 'friendly' is North Korea?)
And this is supposed to be so useful for understanding the issues that we should be focused on your favored political goals instead of directly tackling the issues?
Studying human systems is one of the best ways of studying complex systems and systems engineering, which are already crucial for complex engineering projects, like developing a complex AI. Before we can even talk about our future binary overlords being hostile or friendly, we will have to study how basic, but constantly developing, AI integrates and plays off of human social systems. We have to gather quantified data about how two distinct forms of intelligence interact and what, if any, conclusions can be generalized to a future where humans are no longer the species with the highest intelligence.
You have no data about how real AI's would behave in our society except for fiction, which contains no more guidance now than the Bible did for 16th century astrophysics. We have no consistent models that explain our own intelligence, let alone an artificial one that has yet to exist. You can pontificate about Plato's ideal Terminator but it won't make a bit of difference until we get our telescope.
What does it mean to study a generic 'complex system' and 'systems engineering' and what does this have to do with estimating the potential risks and dangers?
> we will have to study how basic, but constantly developing, AI integrates and plays off of human social systems.
This presumes you already know all about what the AI will be and is putting the cart before the horse.
> We have to gather quantified data about how two distinct forms of intelligence interact and what, if any, conclusions can be generalized to a future where humans are no longer the species with the highest intelligence.
Consider an aborigine making this argument: 'we have observed their firearms and firewater, and know there are many unknowns about these white men in their large canoes; if we look at their capabilities, our best analyses and research and extrapolations certainly suggest they could be a serious threat to us, but we must reserve judgement and quantify data about how our forms of intelligence will interact with theirs'.
> You have no data about how real AI's would behave in our society except for fiction, which contains no more guidance now than the Bible did for 16th century astrophysics
Really? We know nothing about AI and our best guesses are literally as good as random tribal superstitions?
> We have no consistent models that explain our own intelligence, let alone an artificial one that has yet to exist.
Someone tell the psychologists and the field of AI they have learned nothing at all which could possibly inform our attempts to understand these issues.
I don't think it's any more arrogant than, say, Djikstra pointing out that submarines move in a completely different manner than a human swimmer. How arrogant were the Wright brothers in looking at birds and deciding to try to achieve some of the same goals by a completely different mechanism?
If computers thought the same way humans did, if they came with builtin moral sentiments, the product of a very unusual evolutionary history and social structure, if they had access to no novel capabilities, then humans and forms of cooperation developed over the last few eyeblinks (centuries) might be relevant. But then, no one would care about the issue in the first place...
Sure, the corporations will fight back through lobbying etc. but at the end of the day we are still talking about the human intelligence of the corporate masters versus the collective intelligence of the citizenry. So the strategy of the corporation is not a form of artificial intelligence. Most importantly, the corporate masters fully realize that they live in a symbiosis with the rest of the society so they will not pursue paths that threaten the human civilization, for example they will not engage in nuclear war.
Unfriendly AI on the other hand, is an artificial life form capable of superhuman intelligence that has no necessary symbiosis with humans. It will view humans in the same way we look at apes: an inferior life form from our past evolution that can be preserved in reservations, studied and certainly destroyed if it grows to the point of competing for our resources. Bonus, they will likely be imune to high doses of radiations and have a fault tolerant distributed architecture specifically designed to survive nuclear war.
Yeah, I find this (that financial actors are acting in a hostile manner) more tenable than the impression I took from your blog post, which was that the financial system itself was acting with intentionality.
> look at existing economic and social systems where disparate individual goals are coordinated into cooperative or conflicting action
I hope you can bring that perspective to the table; I've noticed that a lot of the public work is about preserving goals while modifying structure, while actually mediating between conflicting goals/values is a bit handwavey.
And yeah, I hope we're far away from human level AI, but we're talking about our uncertainty on conceptual distance to an undiscovered theoretical framework, here. It's not quite as bad as trying to guess when the Riemann Hypothesis will be resolved, but it has that quality.
Why do you think this? The idea behind the Singularity is that even an AI that starts far below human-level, but is capable of recursive self-modification, can bootstrap itself to superintelligence. We don't need to understand the human brain to create such an AI; we need only to:
A. create a the simplest of "digital animals", and
B. give it the capability to push itself into self-directed Lamarckian evolution to satisfy its preferences;
C. and have this all happen on electronic time-scales (e.g. successive "generations" being created in milliseconds or less),
and we'll likely see a Singularity.
> look at existing economic and social systems where disparate individual goals are coordinated into cooperative or conflicting action, and how the results are related to human goals and human flourishing.
"Existing economic and social systems" allow humans to cooperate with humans. The whole point of FAI research is to figure out how to make an AI that is "human"-enough that it would have cause to participate in such systems with us.
A paperclip-maximizer has nothing to gain from participating in a stock market, or an election. People do not want to be turned into paperclips, and it does not want paperclip-resources turned to human ends. Its goals are not disparate, but rather incompatible with our own.
A non-Friendly AI should not be conceptualized by your intuition as a certain kind of human that we can possibly learn to "live-and-let-live." It can, at best, be conceptualized as something like a Baby-Eating Alien[1]. Usually, though, it would seem to us something more akin to a supermassive black hole: an unlimited force that consumes many things we want and outputs nothing useful to us, that we must keep away from, and especially must avoid creating in the laboratory.
Also, evolution optimizes for survival and reproduction, not intelligence. While it may be possible to design an artificial evolutionary system that optimizes for superintelligence, I don't think doing so is trivial (or it would have been done).
Let's posit that your image of post-singularity non-friendly AIs is accurate. They are an immense and irresistible force, like a black hole. I can imagine something like that, but I have a great deal of difficulty imagining something like that that is also constrained by initial design decisions made by humans before the singularity, which is what the friendly AI people hope to achieve. To be fair I haven't read all their stuff yet and I'm sure they address this point.
[1] I think I read it in Trevor Kletz' book "What Went Wrong?: Case Histories of Process Plant Disasters".
That's the tough nut to crack. Everything is predicated on that capability. It's not about AI overcoming current challenges. It's also about it overcoming future ones - and evolving fast enough so that it's smart enough at the time it meets those challenges.
All these are non-trivial issues.
I also like the alternative problem that you posit: what can we do about existing semi-autonomous systems whose functioning is harmful to humanity? However, I don't feel very hopeful about any sort of solutions we might have to these problems. Semi-autonomous systems at societal level have existed for probably nearly as long as as humanity itself. Are there some good examples of such systems that were initially harmful but have been carefully cultivated by humanity to make their effects largely beneficial?
1 - The researchers can't program those institutions; 2 - The researchers intend to use AI as a tool for that goal.
Really we have no idea. True nothing around today is remotely close to human intelligence, but the question is; will AI be a slow gradual process, or will someone make a breakthrough and suddenly make a lot of progress very quickly? In any case, it won't happen at all if people aren't working on it.
1) Our current economic system is already a form of AI. Using the wikipedia definition, it is a system that perceives its environment and takes actions that maximize its chances of success. Humans that are in this system are inputs in the environment. They may have individual agency, but cannot direct the system as a whole.
2) The "success" that this AI is maximizing is not currently in line with optimizing human interest.
3) Instead of theorizing about how to make sure a future AI system is in line with human interest, we should look at the current dominant AI and attempt to improve that.
All three of those premises can be argued, and I've come to reasonable arguments on both sides just on my own with a few minutes of thought. But I think those are the premises to argue.
So what? How does this justify his conclusion:
> But they have chosen a fantasy version of the problem, when human interests are being fucked over by actual existing systems right now. All that brain-power is being wasted on silly hypotheticals, because those are fun to think about, whereas trying to fix industrial capitalism so it doesn’t wreck the human life-support system is hard, frustrating, and almost certainly doomed to failure.
Even if the finance industry / corporations are a parasite, so what? That doesn't wish away AI: AI will still remain a threat (or not a threat) regardless of whether Goldman Sachs is dissolved. Threats are not a zero-sum game: if you show that finance is a parasite, that doesn't suddenly alter the universe to guarantee AI is safe and easy.
Even if we interpret him charitably as making a nuanced cost-effectiveness argument that 'we face many threats, have very limited resources, and corporations are more cost-effective to fight than working on AI', that still seems pretty darn unlikely. Corporations are a major political issue which attract the attention and effort of hundreds of thousands of people and inspire real world action like Occupy Wall Street; why does this fight need a few more people in it? Diminishing returns set in a very long time ago. And fundamentally, financial types have (or have not) been parasites throughout history. Their impact is bounded. They are not anything new under the sun.
Whereas with AI, we don't know whether AI will ever exist; whether the impact will be huge or close to zero; hardly anyone takes it remotely seriously (quick question: have you ever read a mainstream article which did not make either a _Termintor_ or 'Rapture of the Nerds' allusion?); and the sum total of all efforts on thinking about the topic is, what, maybe $7m a year? (Google's safety board + MIRI + FHI + the new existential risk org whose name escapes me). You have to assume some pretty extreme values to make cost-effectiveness criterion spit out 'nobody should be thinking about AI! Everyone should be swotting up their Marx!'
Conflating socially-harmful corporations with 'hostile AI' does both topics a disservice.