Re:Internet Tolls And The Case For Strong Net Neutrality
by dragonwriter on Friday March 21, 2014 @02:04PM
(#7443718)
> True however if it was used for legitimate proposes like by Netflix what's your excuse for throttling if it's not piracy.
Without the Open Internet rules that were struck down, the excuse is "we're a for profit business, and (1) Netflix is a fat stream of revenue that we are enabling and we don't see a reason to do that without getting a big cut, and (2) Anyway, Netflix is competing with our streaming video services which are one of our major sources of revenue, so if our customers have degraded access to Netflix, that just makes our service that Netflix competes with more attractive, and brings us more revenue. So, considering both of those factors, its win-win for us to provide Netflix the choice of (1) give us more of your money, or (2) have your service work less-well, if at all, for our customers."
This is, fairly exactly, the kind of harm that Open Internet order was designed to prevent -- to the extent that broadband providers that are also video (cable TV or internet streaming) providers discriminating against competing video services was one of the things called out to illustrated what was prohibited by the non-discrimination provision.
Without the Open Internet rules that were struck down, the excuse is "we're a for profit business, and (1) Netflix is a fat stream of revenue that we are enabling and we don't see a reason to do that without getting a big cut, and (2) Anyway, Netflix is competing with our streaming video services which are one of our major sources of revenue, so if our customers have degraded access to Netflix, that just makes our service that Netflix competes with more attractive, and brings us more revenue. So, considering both of those factors, its win-win for us to provide Netflix the choice of (1) give us more of your money, or (2) have your service work less-well, if at all, for our customers."
This is, fairly exactly, the kind of harm that Open Internet order was designed to prevent -- to the extent that broadband providers that are also video (cable TV or internet streaming) providers discriminating against competing video services was one of the things called out to illustrated what was prohibited by the non-discrimination provision.