Re:Tesla Can Topple the Car-Dealer Monopoly
by mikeash on Thursday March 20, 2014 @02:00PM
(#7437375)
You can get a better deal because of it, but how often do you? Most people do not.
In other words, the current system offers benefits to the best negotiators, and screws everyone else. I'd rather even that out, especially since there will be plenty of competition between car makers anyway.
I don't know that people really get zero-profit or below-cost deals. I'm sure they think they do, but when people say that they're typically (not always, and not saying you're doing this) looking only at the car's invoice price, and ignoring holdbacks.
(For those unaware, manufacturers typically pay out a sum of money to the dealer when the dealer sells the car. This effectively reduces the invoice price of the car but, crucially, doesn't reduce the actual number on the invoice. Thus, you could buy a car "at cost" and the dealer still makes a profit because they get extra money afterwards.)
In other words, the current system offers benefits to the best negotiators, and screws everyone else. I'd rather even that out, especially since there will be plenty of competition between car makers anyway.
I don't know that people really get zero-profit or below-cost deals. I'm sure they think they do, but when people say that they're typically (not always, and not saying you're doing this) looking only at the car's invoice price, and ignoring holdbacks.
(For those unaware, manufacturers typically pay out a sum of money to the dealer when the dealer sells the car. This effectively reduces the invoice price of the car but, crucially, doesn't reduce the actual number on the invoice. Thus, you could buy a car "at cost" and the dealer still makes a profit because they get extra money afterwards.)