Re:Why Open Source misses the point of Free Software
by zanny on Thursday March 20, 2014 @12:26PM
(#7436555)
I was going to write something up to the guy above you, but you nailed all my points. Good show!
> Even today, the free software movement is developing new licenses to combat a new threat: hardware that will only run an approved version of an open source program.
And a lot of people miss that this is why they wrote the GPLv3 in the first place, and why it is such a big deal that the Linux kernel doesn't adopt it.
Re:Why Open Source misses the point of Free Software
by dragonwriter on Thursday March 20, 2014 @12:27PM
(#7436569)
> Even today, the free software movement is developing new licenses to combat a new threat: hardware that will only run an approved version of an open source program.
You mean, like the GPLv3, which restricts the freedom to choose such software to business users?
There's nothing wrong with creating groups, as long as nobody forces me to be a member. I'll read about open source vs free software, but I think you know my view: I'm against IP because I'm against legal fictions, because they violate natural property rights.
No one is forcing you to become a member of New York City or your particular town or state. You can move.
What anarchists are really lamenting is the lack of available space where people havent set up a group with a government. That just goes to show how it emerges naturally out of other states, which can briefly be described as close to anarchist. And sometimes those states arent so glamorous.
Anyway it's the same in software. It takes massive effort to build a system that is completely free for everybody. That is what the Free Software movement has done. But they are besieged at every turn by PRIVATE, proprietary interests such as businesses who lick their lips and want the "freedom" to use the software those guys built to RESTRICT the freedom of THEIR users. So the Free Software Foundation and its allies have a great ally in the US government and copyright laws! They use them specifically to banish infringers who would use software licensed under GNU License for example without giving their users freedoms.
Interesting? Government helping keep people more free. Thats what happens when the perps are private companies and not governments.
And to address your point - it is just as hard to move away from Windows and Mac, or from Android, iPhone and Blackberry all of them etc. as it is for you to move from the United States. Sure it's possible. But first you need a massive effort to build a natio-- err I mean a platform that is based on principles of freedom. And along the way you will need the help of governments to defend it from people easily coming in and ruining the whole thing because they were "free" to take what you built for their own selfish interests.
The dynamics are almost exactly the same! But it's an interesting case study because software battles are virtual, hurt less people, and softwrae moves really fast. Yet you can actually see the problems that would happen with anarchy without enforcement.
Even today, the free software movement is developing new licenses to combat a new threat: hardware that will only run an approved version of an open source program.