I'm not saying that today's processors are too complex to understand, I'm saying that the software running in the machine in front of me is too complex. I wouldn't mind writing assembly code for a modern processor at all.
But if we are talking about what's likely to make me happy, it's probably a relatively simple CPU, some I/O ports and a soldering iron.
That's probably like the farmer wishing a had a kitchen garden and was growing enough food for himself.
While I like to mention my much beloved Apple II, even a 8088 PC running DOS is somewhat understandable.
This article isn't talking about efficiency, it's talking about joy -- the basis of all hobbies.
Folks designing processors haven't believed that since before the Pentium was introduced. (I went to dinner with some of the MIPS principals right after the first Pentium tech talk. Their conclusion was that everyone would finally figure out that the RISC/CISC wars were over and they'd lost.)
There are lots of things that go into designing a high performance processor. Instruction decoding and its consequences have little effect/cost compared to everything else.
Yup, MIPS and SUN are a thriving companies and Intel shut down.
> However, the actual processor implementation is designed with CPU microcode, which is a RISC architecture. Even when you think you are doing something "CISCy" in an Intel proc, it's translated to RISC behind the scene.
Do you really think that RISC machines don't have microcode? (They also have multi-cycle instructions and the like.)
The claim was that RISC ISAs had inherent advantages that would cause CISC ISAs to be uncompetitive. That claiim was wrong.
Now that mobile devices are becoming as important or more important than PCs, the field has changed. Also, it's possible that RISC's parallel processing advantages will matter given the current trend toward multiple processors and multiple cores.
What are these "parallel processing advantages"?
The claim was that RISC had certain advantages that would have significant performance or cost consequences. That hasn't happened. ARM wins where it wins for reasons that have nothing to do with RISC/CISC.
I also think the two basic premises of the article are just plain wrong. There are plenty of examples where people have written their own operating system from scratch for the x86, there have been articles posted on HN describing as much. So to say that todays processors are "to complex to understand" is just wrong. On the assertion that programming has devolved into "learning another man's APIs" that's just a fact of engineering I suspect the Z80 had a thick manual describing all of it's interfaces and inner workings. The AVR micro controllers I've worked with, the same ones on the Ardunio the author says is still "fun", have a manual that is over 320 pages long describing in effect the processor's API.