News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Extract Chords From YouTube Videos by jws on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @03:01PM (#7430905)
Very nice. I just ran a half dozen varying songs which we perform through it and it mostly matches my chord sheets.

For some bands this will be a dynamic changer. Singers who can not write down chords sometimes don't want to impose on the instrumentalists by bringing in new material. If they can bring in a rough whack that barrier is lifted.

Some notes:

• Not all music is in 4/4. Ok, mixed meter and obscure meter, but 3/4 really ought to be either recognized, or let me tell you. Even when the song is in 4/4, it sometimes loses track of where "1" is.

• It doesn't like to (maybe can't) write more than a 3 note chord, and I didn't see any "sus" chords, but maybe I didn't feed it a good sample. Not understanding 4 note chords will probably add ambiguity to the results, say a Em7 being mistaken for a G if there isn't enough E going on.

• It appears to cache well. When I hit popular songs through their cleanest YouTube URL the results pop up instantly. Well done!

Looking forward to progress, but it goes in the toolbox now.

There are no comments on this comment yet.