The "hackers" FD's moderator is talking about are the ones I'm talking about. They aren't MIT students ordering sweet and sour bitter melon.
Gotta admit, I thought the same thing. Then I'm reminded of patent and trademark law...
The only Silicon Valley moral is making money.
http://www.ritholtz.com/blog/2014/03/dealbook-misunderstands...
Not to mention the scum like Angelo Mozillo who gave us the financial crisis.
What's that a reference to?
I'm weakly willing to bet that whoever you think the "cool kids" were actually sucked.
PLA, 303, cdc/l0pht, DoC ... there was precious little technical skill there (although there was some).
However, I'll take a CuervoCon over a pycon and a swamp ratte stage performance over a Steve Jobs presentation any day of the week.
If your comment reflects sincerely held beliefs that accurately represent the scene as it was, I think it's safe to say you were not a part of it. Your derision of that culture is either out of dishonesty or ignorance.
Claim: for any given period of the hacker scene, saying it largely amounted to nothing more than things like carding and harassment is false, and this statement would only be made by someone who either: (a) was not exposed, or exposed only to a poor sample, and therefore doesn't understand the culture (ignorance); or (b) was exposed, but intentionally wishes to misrepresent the situation (dishonesty)
So I guess the possibilities are either that your statement was ignorant, dishonest, or my claim is wrong and the hacker scene (during whatever time period you intended) was in fact nothing more than dishonorable carders and trolls.
If nothing else, you must know that rming a compromised unix box was not the norm.
What I don't understand is how someone who was around in the 90s could manage to mythologize a bunch of teenagers using semicolons and pipe filters to pop shells on boxes and dump mail spools.
Here's the part where you tell me that you once knew a hacker who never rm'd a box. Why am I meant to care about that? There was zero correlation in the 90s between skill and care for other people's data.
Your opening comment was, "sounds like someone wasn't in the cool kids group". Now you've moved the goalposts; turns out you weren't talking about the "cool kids" at all. But it doesn't matter whether we're talking specifics or the broader issue of whether hackers were more or less moral in the 1990s: you're comprehensively wrong. Consider resetting the "tptacek is always full of shit" bit that is obviously stuck in your brain.
I'm not mischaracterizing tptacek's comment. Nor am I suggesting that there were no bad actors.
tptacek said: "The "hackers" FD's moderator is talking about are the ones I'm talking about.", those being "teenagers breaking into phone switches and harassing people, buying Pantera CDs on stolen credit cards, stealing ESNs from other people's phones to make calls on someone else's bill, and rm'ing Unix boxes".
Obviously, this is not who the FD moderator was talking about, making tptacek's comment unfair.
pg 1678 days ago | link
Everything you've written would have been just as true in the 1980s, with a few of the names changed. Then too there were authentic hackers, glib fakers, and corporate drones.
The great majority of the computer world in the 1980s was profoundly unsubversive. The smart, subversive people were a tiny minority. They seem a larger proportion when you look back from 30 years later, because the fakers and PHBs had no lasting effects.
10 years from now, who is going to remember Marc Andreessen or Paul Graham? Besides some true hacker enthusiast ironically, who remembers Andressen's work on Netscape. In my original post in 2009, I mentioned the hot founder celebrities back then, Carol Bartz (fired), Seth Godin (pumping out more irrelevant books listed further down on Amazon) and Timothy Ferris (moved on from 4-hour "founding" to 4-hour body-building and cooking).I think in the early nineties, when Linus Torvald first pushed out Linux on the listserv. We had OS/2 Warp and Windows 3.0 preview and Microsoft Bob. Borland, WordPerfect, Lotus 123 running on MS-DOS were the kings. Do you guys remember who founded or worked on those? The people who hack on stuff will always be there because money & fame didn't motivate them in the first place.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qHE_XGtUNx4
(Wear Sunscreen)
Truly PG's lack of self-awareness (or cynical dishonesty) is mind-boggling.
Err. Now I do like that book. But this might be overstating the case.
The Little Schemer
The Seasoned Schemer
SICP
Lisp In Small Pieces
Practical Common Lisp
But it's not the point.
Full-disclosure is all of security-hackers. And the sad thing is that there is no more honour amongst security-hackers. In the 90s they used to share 0-days. Today, well if you don't sell it you're a fool.
I'm so sad I missed that period, IRC, the lulz.
Don't confuse the hacker spirit with the hacker word.
this is what a hacker stands for https://w2.eff.org/Censorship/Internet_censorship_bills/barl...
http://www.reddit.com/r/netsec/comments/20sxd2/full_disclosu...
It's at best trying to compare a painter that does portraits to a painter that paints automobiles. Both require skills, but in completely different areas.
Agreed.
There was a certain "code" people adhered to. Even groups like LOD wouldn't release exploits because they feared people would use them for nefarious purposes.
In short, in the 1990's there were huge amounts of full disclosure, and even those trying to work with vendors were usually snubbed by those vendors. It was a completely different landscape.
There is no honour amongst hackers any more.
10-20 years back a term hacker had a close relation to a certain moral conduct emphasizing freedom of knowledge. Today with a mass market of startups, that was largely popularized by Hacker News, this perception has changed. A hacker now is a founder. He must be good at raising money, monetizing a product and the greatest feat of all - exit. There's no more moral obligations of the past. Launch at all cost - the rest is an afterthought.
There's a discrepancy between the two cultures. I think this divide is the source of the mailing-list problem and problems with freedom of information and privacy at large we have today.