Ding ding ding! That's the trouble: we've gotten people in a state where they're sensitive to the very last dollar in price. People will actually pick the worse ticket just to save $5.
I used to work at an online retailer where part of our job was to market environmentally-friendly, recyclable, easy-to-open (read: no clamshell, no thick plastic) packaging to customers. We did some research into the price premium people are willing to pay for the lack of hassle. The answer was close to zero.
This is a classic race to the bottom, I have no ideas on how to fix it.
Regarding airlines, I think the issue is one of temporal duration. I'm willing to suck it up for one (or two) 8 hour flights. It's uncomfortable, but whatever, it's over. I'm not going to pay an extra $100 to spare myself some temporary discomfort.
If, on the other hand, airlines offered some kind of subscription service (a la Amazon Prime) where I could pay $200/year to spare myself all future discomfort by getting a "free" upgrade to economy-plus on any flights I take, then I might be interested.
That's a bad example. There's ways to "pay" for sex other than just handing cash directly to the "other participant". In fact, most sex probably is not "free", if analyzed sufficiently carefully. Even if we count the monetary value of time at zero.
Given that Continental's management decided to keep E+ when they effectively took over United, my guess is the numbers were convincing enough that E+ was worth the loss in total seats.
1.) Flexible seating in aircraft so that each seat can be adjusted forward/backwards between flights by flight attendants. Doing this by seat might be awkward for people sitting next to each other, so maybe do it by row.
2.) Bidding-style airline tickets. How much would you pay for the minimum amount of room? How much would you pay to get the maximum amount of room? How much would you pay to be allowed to recline the seat? How much would you pay to prevent the guy in front of you from reclining the seat?
These sound like terrible ideas, but in the airline spirit of dynamic pricing I think it fits.
Indeed, he got the upgrade: the premium economy section was otherwise empty. Otherwise, the situation would have been beyond unpleasant for everyone around him.
The cheapest seats are so small that they need to have at least a few with more space for this type of case. If they can sell them to comfort-sensitive people for a higher price, even better.
Having done a couple of 12 hour stretches while holding a small child in my lap, I'd definitely agree with you on making it more comfortable :)