News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Glass Walls: Partial Solution to The Glass Ceiling? by Spooky23 on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @03:46PM (#7424511)
I guess I work in a different universe where people behave themselves better.

If anyone talking to anybody in private front of a group of people is a potentially salacious event, the level of paranoia and tension in that place is out of control. At one point, all of my direct reports were women -- if they felt anxious to have a private conversation with me in my office or stairwell, that's a huge problem, and I couldn't have been effective at my job.

Re:Glass Walls: Partial Solution to The Glass Ceiling? by tunesmith on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @04:04PM (#7424628)
I agree... I don't tend to think anything of having break room or stairwell conversations with people that are far away in the organizational chart, and I don't worry that people will think there's an affair or conspiracy or something creepy going on if someone sees me talking to them. I don't really see the flaw in just taking everyone at face value, and making sure my business communications are restricted to saying exactly what I mean, no more no less. I generally expect others to take me at face value, too - if they don't, I see that as unprofessional since they could always ask me clarifying questions rather than attempt to read my tea leaves.
Re:Glass Walls: Partial Solution to The Glass Ceiling? by Mz on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @03:56PM (#7424571)
An extremely popular man was fired two days earlier (for either sexual harassment or an affair or both). Tensions in the department were crazy high that week. It was not a normal situation. That was a factor in my decision to not speak with him at that time.
Re:Glass Walls: Partial Solution to The Glass Ceiling? by facepalm on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @04:15PM (#7424683)
I hope it was sexual harassment, or can you really be fired for having an affair?
Re:Glass Walls: Partial Solution to The Glass Ceiling? by SwellJoe on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @04:23PM (#7424743)
In many companies the policy is that people in positions of power can't have relationships with their underlings. i.e. a VP having sex with their executive assistant would probably cross the line into unethical behavior on a number of fronts. Even if both parties entered it willingly and with no coercion or implied retaliation for saying "no", there may be questions of favoritism among other employees. The assistant would never be able to rise within the company without that doubt creeping in about their competence.

So, if it's not the official policy in an office, it is probably still grounds for action, since most offices expect a certain level of ethical behavior toward coworkers.

Re:Glass Walls: Partial Solution to The Glass Ceiling? by existencebox on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @09:06PM (#7426198)
As someone who has been first working alongside and later as overseeing engineer for my fiancee (both as programmers over the last few years), this saddens me a little bit. Not to suggest that I don't see why things like this might cause problems, but that for me (and for my boss, who is a researcher along side his wife) it's been an overwhelmingly positive and productive experience.
Re:Glass Walls: Partial Solution to The Glass Ceiling? by SwellJoe on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @09:48PM (#7426357)
Some companies simply require relationships to be reported to HR. There are tons of different ways to deal with the problem. But, it definitely is an ethical dilemma. I tend to recommend to friends that they avoid office romances unless the romance is more important than the job to them, especially in situations where there is a power imbalance.
Re:Glass Walls: Partial Solution to The Glass Ceiling? by unreal37 on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @10:40PM (#7433482)
Working alongside your gf or wife is one thing. But if she reports to you, do you get to decide her annual review rating? Do you decide her raises? If she's not doing her fair share of work, do you warn her and then fire her?

There are reasons why managers can't generally have relationships with a direct report. HR at my company forbids it.

Re:Glass Walls: Partial Solution to The Glass Ceiling? by existencebox on Thursday March 20, 2014 @08:01AM (#7434982)
There may be some truth in to that. I do contribute to her annual review and am responsible for making sure she's completing work effectively, but I don't decide raises or determine firing, which are probably the most powerful capabilities one can have.

That being said, perhaps this is a way to work around the normal pitfalls, where if there is a potential conflict, the person in question can be a "practical" manager, but perhaps not a "supervisory" manager. Those are horrible words for it, but I mean in that one manager would be actively overseeing the work, and the other would be a lower level of involvement check/balance against the former. It may be more manpower to do this, but it's generally how the engineering teams here work out anyway; that there are the engineers who have been here longer overseeing the new hires in the work, with a more uninvolved formal supervisory structure as well.

(This has other problems, I'll openly add, but has allowed for a situation like mine to exist, so it does make me look twice.)

Sorry for the essay, this ended up being a lot longer than I had originally intended.

Re:Glass Walls: Partial Solution to The Glass Ceiling? by facepalm on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @04:50AM (#7427395)
I've seen various statistics, but I think up to 20% of marriages are between people who met at work. That's why I also tend to remain skeptic about that approach to the issue (to simply forbid relationships between employees).
Re:Glass Walls: Partial Solution to The Glass Ceiling? by facepalm on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @04:30PM (#7424790)
That makes sense, thanks.
Re:Glass Walls: Partial Solution to The Glass Ceiling? by aestra on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @12:42PM (#7429902)
Some companies have explicit "no fraternization" policies which forbid sexual relations between employees. Also some allow it, but it has be publicly disclosed and the two can't be, for example, in the same department or one can't be a supervisor of the other. If he was high up in the chain (depending on the organization), it can be assumed/argued having an affair would be unwanted because he becomes a target for blackmail and becomes a reason for termination. You also generally are disallowed to have sexual relations with a customer.

Also certain organizations forbid higher ranking and lower ranking people to even hang out outside of work, develop close personal relationships, or even have about personal/non-work conversations. Many militaries operate this way. My sister also worked for an organization that had this policy.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraternization

Re:Glass Walls: Partial Solution to The Glass Ceiling? by Spooky23 on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @07:44PM (#7425875)
At Wal-Mart, dating a coworker is grounds for termination.
Re:Glass Walls: Partial Solution to The Glass Ceiling? by johnbm on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @12:48PM (#7429960)
So that's reason to treat employees like lepers and impose your paranoia on them? You weren't taking his feelings into a count, you simply declared them as something to be managed, and you as the authority. Did it ever occur to you that you might've been wrong?
Re:Glass Walls: Partial Solution to The Glass Ceiling? by joe_the_user on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @04:49PM (#7424870)
I think the problem being discussed is fairly start-up specific. And moreover, I think it kind of involves an assumption that start-up organization structures are the direction in which organizations in general should be going. As far as I can tell, start-up organization structure is as informal as possible. The aim is to leverage trust and flexibility that can be found in a group of close friends.

I would point out that moving in this direction is moving in a sort-of opposite direction to the direction that society went when we human made the transition to a modern capitalist/bureaucratic society. The reason you have bureaucracy, human resource, job descriptions and all the rest is that this allows a person to be separated from a job. There's lots of inveigling against "being a cog in a machine" but it should be remembered that a cog has clear obligations and clear rewards. And the cog is essentially a compartment - a person's social life, relationship involvement, cultural values and whatnot are kept at arms length. And it is a bit clunky, bureaucracy implies people aren't using these factors as means to make quicker decisions.

So in a sense, "chucking all the bureaucracy" sort of guarantees that you will have a situation where a monoculture of something will dominate. Because someone similar to the existing group can most easily "fit right in". And the aim is quick, unmediated action rather than any formal processes. (Edit: and the easiest monoculture is young white men but that would just be an example, not a PC inveigling again this particular group).

In the bureaucratic paradigm, a chat with a boss shouldn't involve implication of friendship and from there relationship interest - and in a well-function bureaucracy, it doesn't. In a start-up, the implications of a chat are totally informal and thus the implication of friend would be there and so the implication of relationship interest can easily appear - the bad part of "no walls" is clearest.

Re:Glass Walls: Partial Solution to The Glass Ceiling? by Spooky23 on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @07:43PM (#7425869)
That's bizarre to me. I guess I haven't had startup experience, so I don't get it. That sounds like high school cliquish ness to me -- the opposite of trust and flexibility.