Re:Doctor: ADHD, as currently defined, does not exist
by exelius on Monday March 17, 2014 @04:45PM
(#7417977)
I won't dispute that the definition of ADHD as it exists in clinical guidelines is entirely too broad. I do think that there is a "condition" that exists in a smaller subset of the population that is described by the guidelines of ADHD, and it's not a sleep disorder or anything like that (in fact, my ADHD is far worse if I sleep too much.)
But the article is potentially harmful because it discounts this population and pretends that there's nothing there. The author says "there is no such thing as ADHD" without allowing for the possibility that there actually is, but it's far too broadly applied and needs to be tightened up.
I didn't get that from the article at all.
He's not saying people don't have problems, he's saying the label ADHD is doing a disservice. It's not a condition, it's a symptom.
If we had a label called "breathing problems" and just lumped all lung-related stuff in there, it would be problematic too. That doesn't mean no one has lung problems, it means we need more narrow diagnosis such as pneumonia, cancer, cystic fibrosis, bronchitis, asthma, etc.
The article is completely right. Any disorder that fits 90%+ of the population is too broad. Either it needs to be split into multiple disorders or the criteria need to be tightened.
This is a categorization article, not a "there's no such thing as ADHD they're all faking it, work harder slackers" article.