News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Doctor: ADHD, as currently defined, does not exist by DanielBMarkham on Monday March 17, 2014 @02:50PM (#7417180)
So I'm with you. I also suffer from attention span issues. It's been a terrible thing to have to live with at times.

But I have to ask an honest question: do you have a deficiency for which you need treatment? Or do you have a personality type which might make you unsuited for certain types of work? Or -- more likely -- do you have a tendency for a type of personality attribute expression which varies depending on various external stimuli?

I think it's perfectly fine that something like ADHD is a naturally-occurring personality trait and/or state of mind for which we might need medication to overcome. At the same time, I'm not too happy with characterizing it as a disease or dysfunction. I think we are taking people who are acting in a completely normal fashion and telling them something is broken about them. That ain't right.

In other words, you both might be right. It's not an either-or situation. As we continue to develop our knowledge of the brain, it's a terrible mistake to create some artificial "perfect" personality and mind that any deviation from is a disease. Very. Bad.

Re:Doctor: ADHD, as currently defined, does not exist by JoeAltmaier on Monday March 17, 2014 @03:25PM (#7417441)
Why is it ok, if its 'natural' or a native trait? My eyes are bad; should I go around without glasses to prove some ethical point?

No, ADHD exists, my family exhibits it (3 generations now and counting), and it can be harnessed, treated or ignored with wildly differing outcomes.

Harnessing and treating it are vastly preferable to ignoring it.

Re:Doctor: ADHD, as currently defined, does not exist by jaggederest on Monday March 17, 2014 @03:08PM (#7417304)
I would argue that the vast majority of people diagnosed with ADHD don't fit the DSM V criteria for a disorder. They're experiencing "an expectable response to common stressors", and probably not "reflecting an underlying psychobiological dysfunction" - they're human, humans are often distracted, this is not a disease until it gets to the level where it absolutely begins to destroy your life, and even then it's probably reflective of something else going on rather than a primary disease.

The key to anything as a disorder in the DSM is that it:

Features

A a behavioral or psychological syndrome or pattern that occurs in an individual

B the consequences of which are clinically significant distress (e.g., a painful symptom) or disability (i.e., impairment in one or more important areas of functioning)

C must not be merely an expectable response to common stressors and losses (for example, the loss of a loved one) or a culturally sanctioned response to a particular event (for example, trance states in religious rituals)

D that reflects an underlying psychobiological dysfunction

E that is not solely a result of social deviance or conflicts with society

F that has diagnostic validity using one or more sets of diagnostic validators (e.g., prognostic significance, psychobiological disruption, response to treatment)

G that has clinical utility (for example, contributes to better conceptualization of diagnoses, or to better assessment and treatment)

Other Considerations

H no definition perfectly specifies precise boundaries for the concept of either “medical disorder” or “mental/psychiatric disorder”

I diagnostic validators and clinical utility should help differentiate a disorder from diagnostic “nearest neighbors”

J when considering whether to add a psychiatric condition to the nomenclature, or delete a psychiatric condition from the nomenclature, potential benefits (for example, provide better patient care, stimulate new research) should outweigh potential harms (for example, hurt particular individuals, be subject to misuse)

Re:Doctor: ADHD, as currently defined, does not exist by JohnBooty on Monday March 17, 2014 @05:18PM (#7418166)

  But I have to ask an honest question: do you have a deficiency for which
  you need treatment? Or do you have a personality type which might make 
  you unsuited for certain types of work? Or -- more likely -- do you have 
  a tendency for a type of personality attribute expression which varies 
  depending on various external stimuli?

  I think it's perfectly fine that something like ADHD is a naturally-
  occurring personality trait and/or state of mind for which we might need 
  medication to overcome. At the same time, I'm not too happy with 
  characterizing it as a disease or dysfunction. I think we are taking 
  people who are acting in a completely normal fashion and telling them 
  something is broken about them. That ain't right.
I love the way you put this, and I agree with a lot of what you said. BUT I also don't think what you say is incompatible with treating focus issues as a problem that can be helped by medication.

For me, learning about ADHD was very liberating!

It wasn't a diagnosis that told me I was fundamentally broken as a person; it was exactly the opposite.

I had a lot of love and support growing up in the 80s and early 90s, don't get me wrong. But I also got a lot of negative reinforcement and had come to think of myself (as a certain book title suggests) as "lazy, stupid, or crazy" (ok - maybe just lazy or crazy) when it came to focus and procrastination issues. I never even considered ADD/ADHD because as far as I knew, it was a label for hyperactive kids and I was never hyperactive.

Those are very broad terms, you know? I really felt like there was fundamental shit wrong with me. I grew up believing in hard work but had the hardest time doing homework and taxes and things I didn't want to do.

So learning about and eventually being diagnosed with ADHD really helped the way I feel about myself. Instead of feeling broken on some fundamental level, I came to feel like I had a pretty specific thing to deal with; one that could be helped by medication and proper sleep/diet/environment/exercise.

Edit: I also want to address this one specific thing you said:

  Or do you have a personality type which might make you unsuited 
  for certain types of work?
I can't think of a single line of work that doesn't benefit from an increased ability to focus.

Even entrepreneurs, who are often famously ADHD (or ADHD-like, anyway) in their restlessness and curiosity, need to focus on the mundane stuff sometimes.

And it's not like medication erases those positive ADHD traits either. The fact is that stimulants leave your body pretty quickly, and with something like your Adderall dosage from day to day. If you're responsible and take a little bit less on the days you don't need it, you can take a little more on the days when you need it more. You can tailor the effects a bit depending on your needs on a particular day.

(Note: The medication is far from perfect; it's not for everybody and is not a cure-all. Biologically, stimulants are a very crude way to address one's focus. In my experience, proper sleep/diet/exercise/environment are more important than any medication I've tried.)

Re:Doctor: ADHD, as currently defined, does not exist by DanielBMarkham on Monday March 17, 2014 @06:58PM (#7418696)
I agree. It's the stigma that I'm talking about. Medicating yourself to adjust your ability to focus in order to perform your job? Like I said, count me in for that.

As a society we're going to have to accept that people are different, and that people may need various medications to adjust their performance capabilities to do various things. That doesn't make these people broken! Simply because you are taking some chemical to do X doesn't mean that you are disabled.

This is going to be a big leap for society. Up until now it's all been "If you need drugs, it must be because there's something wrong with you!" Well, not really. We're all "broken" in various degrees....

Re:Doctor: ADHD, as currently defined, does not exist by JohnBooty on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @05:00AM (#7420859)
Yeah. The stigma is a terrible thing, possibly the worst thing about it.

I never, ever mention ADHD in a workplace[1]. Too many misconceptions, and too many people willing to assume that you're trying to make "excuses."

If I have a specific need, such as having a quiet work area for concentration's sake, I don't ever shy away from making my case for it. But I never present it in the context of "having ADHD."

[1] Although perhaps future employers will Google me and see this discussion. :)