News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gravity waves from Big Bang detected by AnimalMuppet on Monday March 17, 2014 @12:50PM (#7416236)
> This pattern, basically a curling in the polarization, or orientation, of the light, can be created only by gravitational waves produced by inflation.

I call BS. "Within our current theories, this pattern can be created only by..." would be a more accurate statement. The arrogance that "with this theory, we understand it all" has been shot down over and over in the history of science.

[Edit: tarrosion noted the caution of experimenters in making sure that the data could not be caused by something else. This is appropriate, and it's good that they have it. You now have one, and only one, theoretical explanation for the data. But the statement in the article that I quoted is still a step too far. It presumes that our existing theories are the only possible ones.]

Re:Gravity waves from Big Bang detected by carbocation on Monday March 17, 2014 @12:53PM (#7416266)
Usually publications are understood within the context of their field. It would be exhausting to list each limitation of your field in every paper, and the limitations are understood by the intended audience.
Re:Gravity waves from Big Bang detected by mcguire on Monday March 17, 2014 @01:07PM (#7416386)
A friend-of-a-friend has the "science religion"---he seems to try to claim that what we "know" now is the closest to absolute truth that we could possibly get, and would therefore make the claim from the article with a straight face. (He seems unfazed by comments that some new discovery tomorrow might invalidate what we "know" now and seems to think that what we would learn would simply be more absolutely true.)

Me, I'm of the opposite philosophy and understand that everything I think I know now is probably wrong. It's just slightly not-as-wrong as last week.

Re:Gravity waves from Big Bang detected by Locke1689 on Monday March 17, 2014 @02:08PM (#7416852)
On the whole of it, your friend is probably more correct than you are:

http://chem.tufts.edu/answersinscience/relativityofwrong.htm

Re:Gravity waves from Big Bang detected by acqq on Monday March 17, 2014 @05:29PM (#7418228)
As an illustration, around 2200 years ago, 200 years before Jesus, a Greek scientist actually measured the curvature of Earth not moving from his town(!) only by observing the shadow of the Sun and cleverly thinking, giving the circumference as "50 times distance between Alexandria and Siena." He didn't have the exact distance then, but knowing that distance today, he measured the circumference of the Earth with the error of less than 0.2%.

http://todaslascosasdeanthony.com/2012/07/03/eratosthenes-ea...

150 years later, still before Jesus, another scientist, Posidonius, repeated the experiment.

Most of the things we confirmed today survived a lot of checks. As Asimov writes it's not that there's much "wrong" in what science knows today, it just that is "incomplete" in the smaller (from the perspective of the common experience) details.

Re:Gravity waves from Big Bang detected by mcguire on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @12:09PM (#7422737)
The difference to me is that "incomplete" means you are missing something: more precise measurements, better calculations, more information. But that is not necessarily the case. You may be able to measure the size of the Earth relatively precisely, but if your theory puts that Earth at the center of the universe, more measurements are going to do little but cause you headaches.

Take the ever-popular conflict between relativity and quantum mechanics. For all intensive purposes [sic], I believe they both work out to about Newtonian mechanics at scales I can easily observe and they both work very well for their different appropriate tasks. But they don't mesh well together, which is another requirement for science. "Incomplete" doesn't begin to describe that situation because I suspect that whatever is going to unify both is going to be as different from either as they are from classical physics.

[As an aside, I've seen Asimov's essay before and while I usually don't have a problem with his writing, in this essay's case I can't get past the fact that it is either very poorly written (if I'm feeling charitable) or a rather silly ad hominem (if I'm not).]

Re:Gravity waves from Big Bang detected by acqq on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @06:06PM (#7425357)
My example is totally orthogonal to the subject of the position of the Earth in the universe, I don't understand what can benefit from bringing the confusion in the discussion.

Your other argument is what scientists are well aware of for decades, so it's a good example of the science knowing its current limits, which again means we can't be wrong if we know the exact limits. We have unmapped terrains that span only first 1e−32 part of the first second! Can you even imagine how small that time is? There were 1e49 such time intervals since then! What's that when not a small "incompleteness" of our knowledge. That people who work on that call it "a big thing to unify" doesn't change the fact that it's something small to the vastness of the time we already cover with the present equations.

Re:Gravity waves from Big Bang detected by jjoonathan on Monday March 17, 2014 @04:11PM (#7417748)
It sounds to me like you agree entirely with your friend and are nitpicking over the how you define the measurement of knowledge (in particular, the sign convention for incorrect-but-more-predictive theories).
Re:Gravity waves from Big Bang detected by BugBrother on Monday March 17, 2014 @01:23PM (#7416493)
Yes, but note that there are differences in how you can work in experimental/historical sciences.

Your friend^2 would probably gain by reading more about the scientific method, see wikipedia etc. (But then, so could probably you and me both, too.)

Re:Gravity waves from Big Bang detected by lhgaghl on Monday March 17, 2014 @02:36PM (#7417072)
These kinds of people are terrible coders. They are made aware of one possible thing that could go wrong in a piece of code they're writing, and once they avoid that trap, they magically think since they avoided that one pitfall, they are on top of their game, and then proceed complacently to write the rest of the code. Months later we find it is full of pitfalls which could have been avoided if they paid attention.
Re:Gravity waves from Big Bang detected by maxjones1 on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @05:37AM (#7420975)
>I call BS. "Within our current theories, this pattern can >be created only by..." would be a more accurate statement. >The arrogance that "with this theory, we understand it all" >has been shot down over and over in the history of science.

I echo your BS call. Arrogance is what this is. And hype.

And this is not totally unrelated to the fact that the experimental physics community is always looking for money. This is more likely just money hype. I am not saying there is something supernatural they are missing. I am just saying they don't understand the universe yet. Yet they are saying they do, and they have their hands out for more money.

Big Bang theory is a form of religion. Thus, I am suspicious of it.

This entire thread is a great example of homo sapiens groupthink.

Re:Gravity waves from Big Bang detected by lomnakkus on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @08:15PM (#7432903)
Are you acquainted with the field and underlying science? If so, could please elucidate your criticisms and make them concrete instead of just throwing about vague accusations of corruption? ("always looking for money", etc.)