Re:MH370: A different point of view
by userbinator on Monday March 17, 2014 @06:47AM
(#7414244)
The part about tire fires producing "horrific incapacitating smoke" seemed a bit odd to me --- the landing gear are located outside the pressurised part of the fuselage.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:MH370: A different point of view
by rosswilson on Monday March 17, 2014 @07:37AM
(#7414438)
Read about Nigeria Airways Flight 2120 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nigeria_Airways_Flight_2120).
An under-inflated tyre caught fire during take-off, the plane took off unaware of the fire, when the landing gear was retracted the fire spread burning through electrical and hydraulic lines.
A fire "outside of the pressurised part of the fuselage" doesn't mean the same didn't happen here.
Re:MH370: A different point of view
by VolatileVoid on Monday March 17, 2014 @08:55AM
(#7414720)
Sure, although the NationAir DC-8 tragedy was a different jet. The 777 is significantly more advanced and I believe has some sort of fire detection in the wheel well; they would have known very shortly after takeoff if there was smoke. Unless we're saying that the fire immediately disabled the ability to communicate the fact that there WAS a fire to the pilots...
...but that seems unlikely too, because I imagine the 777 has backup systems that would alert pilots in case a system as critical as the fire detection equipment in the wheel assembly was not responding.
I'm not saying the fire scenario is impossible; I'm still erring on the side of this being a tragic systems failure, and not a malicious act. I just think it might be entirely unlike anything we've seen in the past.