News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Teach Naked' Effort Strips Computers From Classrooms by Oompa on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @11:51AM (#741421)
This maybe true, but I cringe at the thought of writing code on paper.
Re:'Teach Naked' Effort Strips Computers From Classrooms by mquander on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @12:12PM (#741482)
Well, hopefully nobody is asking you to write legal Java down to the last namespace and semicolon on paper. (I know some classes do this; I think it's foolish.) But writing semi-legal Scheme or pseudocode on paper is easy and no more strange or demanding than doing mathematics on paper. I don't think it deserves a cringe.

Also, if it's some small degree harder to actually physically write the program, I'm not sure that's a bad thing in terms of learning; it encourages you to do more thinking and understanding and less fly-by-wire programming and testing.

Re:'Teach Naked' Effort Strips Computers From Classrooms by mgreenbe on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @12:53PM (#741575)
Absolutely. My early programming courses all had code-writing on the written exams, all in Scheme. (I think Scheme is particularly well-suited to paper, though, because of its minimal syntax and its "general recursion for everything" approach.)

Programming on a computer---particularly in a REPL language like Scheme---tempts one to "just run it". Writing a program on paper requires reflection and planning: good skills, I think.

Re:'Teach Naked' Effort Strips Computers From Classrooms by tsally on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @02:25PM (#741779)
The high school Computer Science AP exam asks you to do this with Java. Missing a semicolon is a minor deduction, but it is still a deduction.
Re:'Teach Naked' Effort Strips Computers From Classrooms by ramchip on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @12:44PM (#741552)
I've had to write 100% legal Matlab, Java and C++ in tests (I study Computer Engineering). All of our exams are on paper only.

Actually, I even had a multiple choice question which asked whether in Matlab it was legal to start a variable name with a number. Not the most important thing to know, IMHO, but introductory programming classes here tend to focus on syntax so that the engineering students can get something done quickly.

Re:'Teach Naked' Effort Strips Computers From Classrooms by yummyfajitas on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @01:17PM (#741626)
Regarding math on paper, I actually find it's easier to do math on computer than on paper. Quick and easy calculations (e.g., less than half a page) are often faster on paper, but the long and involved ones require a computer to manage.

I might have different feelings if I didn't use emacs.

Re:'Teach Naked' Effort Strips Computers From Classrooms by RK on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @02:02PM (#741734)
Are you one of those people who TeX's their notes while sitting in class? I'm always amazed by that. Wish I could pull it off :)

Long calculations are a pain, but I find doing it by hand is good, so that I can go back and find mistakes. I tend to use one long scratch pads, so that I have a sort of ongoing, live revision control. When I use LaTeX I tend to erase stuff, because I want LaTex to look nice, and of course the erased parts might have been useful later.

Re:'Teach Naked' Effort Strips Computers From Classrooms by yummyfajitas on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:51PM (#742153)
I never actually developed note-taking skills. After a semester or two, I gave up on even trying.

Basically, my calculations usually look like this:

interesting quantity < mess[0] < mess[1] < ... < mess[n] < final result

I've found it's very easy to copy mess[j] to a new line, edit, and repeat. It's harder to rewrite mess[j] on paper. Storing complicated expressions in emacs registers is also quite nice.

Re:'Teach Naked' Effort Strips Computers From Classrooms by sp332 on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @12:06PM (#741467)
I wrote code in various languages on paper for tests in college. Even C++ and Java are not horrible if the teacher just asks for you for a code snippet that demonstrates one thing. Obviously "write a whole program that works" assignments were done on a computer :)
Re:'Teach Naked' Effort Strips Computers From Classrooms by pkulak on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @01:48PM (#741711)
I had to write code in college for tests. Didn't bother me at all.