In addition, what Unix mistakes do you see in Singularity, for instance? It's drastically different from Unix-like kernels in effectively every way.
What OSes would you recommend that budding OS developers study, if not these? Amoeba is one of the few I can think of off the top of my head that might fit what you're looking for.
Try this one:
It is just a 512-byte bootblock demo, and yet it does something which no braindead Unix clone can: orthogonal persistence.
Honestly, I'm sort of baffled we're still arguing about this. I can't stand Unix-like kernels, I just believe that this particular tutorial is excellent at teaching the basic concepts required to put together any OS. If you find a tutorial of this sort of quality for any other design, submit it and I'll be certain to upvote it.
The world needs more OS designers, and tutorials of this sort lower the barrier to entry.
Edit: Also, if you're on Freenode by any chance, shoot me a PM (my nick is my username here). I always enjoy talking with someone who's as passionate about OS technology as I am.
Learning has a direct cost in creativity. Once you have mired your brain in cached thoughts (http://lesswrong.com/lw/k5/cached_thoughts/) of Unix brokenness, it is very difficult to dislodge them. They won't feel like cached thoughts, or like anything special for that matter - just "the way you write operating systems."
Not one of the systems you mentioned deviates in any fundamental way from the mistakes of the original Unix. Not one. One of the reasons for this is that each was designed by people who have been steeped in Unix internals.