News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Roll Your Own UNIX Clone by daeken on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @10:45AM (#741299)
It very well could not be, but what's important here isn't what's built, but how it's built. The concepts are important, not the end result. Compared to the vast majority of intro to OS tutorials out there, this is great.

As I said, you can't expect someone to create something original unless they understand the mistakes of the past. I started off implementing toy kernels with no structure, moved on to Unix-like kernels, and eventually ended up in a realm entirely different. Just because someone starts out copying Unix doesn't mean they're going to be blind to other competing designs or completely unique ones.

Expecting someone to build something new without any basis is just foolish.

Re:Roll Your Own UNIX Clone by asciilifeform on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @11:24AM (#741361)
> Expecting someone to build something new without any basis is just foolish

Base it on your mental model of how your CPU's internals ought to be used, as inferred from the latter's manuals - like 1980s microcomputer users did.

Creativity exists.

Re:Roll Your Own UNIX Clone by daeken on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @11:30AM (#741376)
I want to become a musician. If I listen to existing music, my creativity will be limited by what I've learned. Does that mean that listening to music is a bad thing if you want to become a musician?
Re:Roll Your Own UNIX Clone by asciilifeform on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @12:19PM (#741495)
Music is a poor example: a field with unusually rigid cultural norms, where true originality is punished far more often than it is rewarded. So, taming one's creativity by exposure to current norms is exactly how you become a successful (permissibly mildly creative) musician.