I have different machines running different linux distros, so I'm familiar with all the popular package managers (apt-get, yum, pacman), and I must say, Homebrew is really my favorite.
Binary packages are a wonderful thing and a package manager that doesn't support them out of the box isn't a usable solution for the things I do.
Homebrew also doesn't manage OS X itself, which is something I really prefer about apt-get.
The benefit of apt-get source is being able to read the correct version of the source code of any part of the operating system to debug a problem, not necessarily building from source.
Wrong. Homebrew has so-called "bottled" binaries that get "poured in" unless you tell it to build from source or use a flag mandating a custom build.
I'm using the former and it works pretty well for me. Though I wish either of those would use apt-get like Fink did.