Re:Scientists May Get Best View Yet of a Black Hole in Action
by jjoonathan on Saturday March 15, 2014 @10:43PM
(#7407559)
Isn't the nonexistence of large black holes from cosmic ray collisions proof of black hole evaporation? Or have we not been able to measure that / have reason to doubt micro-black-holes are created by cosmic ray collisions in the first place?
Re:Scientists May Get Best View Yet of a Black Hole in Action
by pdonis on Saturday March 15, 2014 @11:22PM
(#7407652)
I would say we don't have accurate enough measurements or an accurate enough theoretical understanding to know how many micro-black-holes we should expect to see from cosmic ray collisions, on the assumption that none of them ever evaporate, or to be able to measure how many there actually are, so as to be able to compare the two numbers to see if there's a significant difference. In principle this would certainly be a good experimental test for the existence of black hole evaporation; I just don't think it's a test we can make with any confidence now or in the near future.
Hawking radiation is a quantum effect, which nobody has ever observed; the reasons for thinking that it exists are purely theoretical.