News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why good managers are so rare by gaius on Friday March 14, 2014 @09:23AM (#7398521)
This should be the sort of thing that the managers above notice, I wonder why they never seem to. Tracking turnover within a team should be a trivial query in any HR system.
Re:Why good managers are so rare by mercer on Friday March 14, 2014 @10:09AM (#7398781)
I think it's a class thing, mostly.

I've been friends with the (competent) managers above a bad manager, and discussed a number of times how bad this manager was. They agreed with my assessment, and yet did nothing about it. I suspect this was partly because they underestimated how much of a disastrous effect this manager had and figured that the unpleasantness of firing him combined with the work of finding someone else would not be worth it. But mainly I think it was because they were 'friendly' with this bad manager (on account of having lunch and meetings together as managers), and because he was 'one of them'.

Maybe if managers are kept from become too much of a tribe some of this could be avoided (assuming that there is competence at some higher level, of course)?

Re:Why good managers are so rare by gaius on Friday March 14, 2014 @10:54AM (#7399096)
Yes, it's interesting, no-one would deny that programmers are tribal. Get two guys together from rival firms, using competing technology stacks, and soon they will set aside any difference and be having a fine old time complaining about "marketing" and their many blunders.

Managers are like this x10. You go to meetups - they go to MBA school. You post on forums - they play golf and go to strip clubs. Rationality goes out of the window when tribal loyalty comes in.

Re:Why good managers are so rare by btilly on Friday March 14, 2014 @09:41AM (#7398622)
They noticed. But by the time that they did, they decided that the lower risk course of action was to stick with the one they had since the people who most disliked her have left, and they didn't know who might like her and leave if she did.

I believe that they made the wrong call. But then again I'm biased, disgruntled, and all the rest of it.

Re:Why good managers are so rare by Shivetya on Friday March 14, 2014 @09:49AM (#7398662)
sadly since most teams don't quit as a whole it can be passed off as bad apples, y'know "that guy didn't like change", and by the time the team is nearly all gone its too late and upper management either forgets or has bigger fish to fry.

There are many signs of bad managers, I am sure we all have them, but my number one is, thinking their title makes them right and beyond question. Got enough of those around to choke a horse. Worse it is usually a symptom that comes from top down and is hard to fix.

Re:Why good managers are so rare by jaredmcateer on Friday March 14, 2014 @10:04AM (#7398749)
In my experience the bad manager will try to sell to their superiors and HR that these were bad apples, they may have done good work but they were toxic to the rest of the team(s). It worked for a while, but it eventually catches up, unfortunately for the company though it's usually well after it's possible to get back the talent they lost.
Re:Why good managers are so rare by mathattack on Friday March 14, 2014 @09:45AM (#7398640)
Generally good managers know when the best are leaving. There are other challenges at work. For instance - if a team is still hitting it's numbers, the manager may not want to make a change. Or there could be no other leadership alternatives. Or they don't want to set the precedent of team mutiny. Hard to know without knowing the details of the situation, but sometimes there is more going on than meets the eye.

And yes - this should be trivial to measure. Hiring a good employee costs X. Of those, 1/Y is a great one. The cost of losing a great one is XY. XY is usually significantly higher than a year's salary.

For the same reason, I also think managers should be rewarded for creating great employees and giving them to the broader organization.

Re:Why good managers are so rare by BSousa on Friday March 14, 2014 @10:20AM (#7398864)
Having seen this happen recently, usually the bad manager always has a good excuse to give your employees are leaving (from there was no bonus to people don't like the color of the office), which masks the problem for a while.