Re:GitHub's language detection is broken
by moron4hire on Friday March 14, 2014 @08:47AM
(#7398361)
I'm looking at more of this, and jesus christ, this is completely wrong:
https://github.com/github/linguist/blob/master/lib/linguist/...
Code that commonly resides in .asp files is completely different from code that commonly resides in .aspx files. They are not synonyms for each other. Also, I would wager that C# aspx files are a tad more common than VB.NET aspx files.
It's even worse than lumping together .c and .cpp. You at least have some chance of getting .c files to compile in a C++ compiler. There is no chance of running ASP code through the ASP.NET engine.
This is why "ASPX" as a term exists, to differentiate from ASP.
In other words, it seems like the overall design wouldn't be hurt too much by just extricating primary_extension completely. Best-case scenario, primary_extension is equivalent to always having at least one item in extensions. It does nothing else.
Also, this looks like a bug: "if possible_languages.length > 1 ... else possible_languages.first" What if length is 0? That's not greater than 1. I'm not familiar with Ruby, does first return null on an empty array, or does it error? LINQ in .NET has separate First<T> and FirstOrDefault<T> methods: one errors, the other returns default(T) (which is null in the case of reference types). Or is there a default match in the index that occurs when no other language is found? https://github.com/github/linguist/blob/master/lib/linguist/...
Not instilling a lot of confidence that someone really thought through this bit of code. I'm not saying I very strictly think through everything I write, but I also don't write software for thousands of users, and I acknowledge that I've grown rather complacent in terms of time spent per unit code.