News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by crdoconnor on Friday March 14, 2014 @05:49AM (#7397727)
He sets up a number of straw men which completely miss the POINT of the financial transactions tax.

>In very brief form, it wasn’t high speed trading, nor any of >the markets where that occurs, which led to the crash.

In very brief form, the financial transactions tax is NOT about preventing another crash (other regulations are needed for this). It's about preventing HFT operators from effectively levying a tax on the rest of the participants in the equities market (e.g. pensions and value investors).

>Reducing speculation increases price volatility

Absurd. In fact, high levels of capital flows correlate with financial crises (i.e. they're a cause of volatility): http://www.crei.cat/people/broner/BDES%20pub.pdf

This can be seen in HFT by looking at the flash crash. Volatility gone nuts. Did that ever happen before HFT?

>the tax itself will not in fact raise any net revenues

Again it's NOT THE POINT of the tax to raise revenues, it's to discourage HFT: http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2013/11/robin-hood-tax-how-re...

>and yet will have a cost to both the workers in the form of lower wages and pensioners in lower pensions.

Not only false, the opposite is true.

The profits that HFT firms make have to come from SOMEwhere, correct? Well, they come from you. Specifically, large investors (pension funds), insurance companies, value investors, etc. Other participants in the market.

HFT takes money directly from pension funds who are executing large orders, by 'skimming' off the orders they make. Their profits are not made out of thin air.

>So an FTT would indeed drive up costs for individual investors making the >critics correct on this very point then?

Nope. FTT is infinitesimally tiny % of a transaction. Unless you're executing millions upon millions of transactions a day that's an infinitesimally tiny amount. In which case you're NOT an individual investor, you're doing HFT... the exact kind of behavior this tax is intended to cut down on.

>Sigh. The argument is now that it’s not going to cost people very much >because we’ve decided not to count that cost which is going to be the >largest for people.

Firstly, HFT WITHDRAWS liquidity precisely when it is needed the most. Most algos will freeze up during times of market distress. So yeah, they're not helping when the markets are ACTUALLY suffering from a lack of liquidity.

Secondly, they're adding trading volume, not liquidity. It was never hard to actually sell or buy a stock before HFT. They're not cutting down on spreads (that's what market makers do - and HFT is NOT market making).

When the markets are operating normally, they're already very, very, very liquid (as was the case before HFT). HFT makes little to no difference.

HFT is basically legalized front running. It should be banned somehow because it is parasitic on the other participants in the equities market. The financial transactions would cut down on that, but don't expect them to give up without a fight (as this guy is witness to).

Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by yxhuvud on Friday March 14, 2014 @06:05AM (#7397775)
> In very brief form, the financial transactions tax is NOT about preventing another crash (other regulations are needed for this). It's about preventing HFT operators from effectively levying a tax on the rest of the participants in the equities market (e.g. pensions and value investors).

Actually no. HFT drive down the costs for pensions and value investors. The ones that foot the bill is the traders and the market makers that have seen their margins collapse.

> This can be seen in HFT by looking at the flash crash. Volatility gone nuts. Did that ever happen before HFT?

Indeed it did. There was a flash crash in 1962 as well. The reason was similar - suddenly the market found they were out of buyers.

> The profits that HFT firms make have to come from SOMEwhere, correct?

Sure, but there are plenty of other players in the market that traditionally have been able to shave a lot more from investors.

As for your comments that HFT is not driving down spreads, there are plenty of evidence that they do. Spreads have collapsed to nothing in the 15-20 years of operating HFTs.

Mandatory reading: http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/hft_apology.html Don't miss part 2 and 3.

Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by crdoconnor on Friday March 14, 2014 @06:23AM (#7397834)
>Actually no. HFT drive down the costs for pensions and value investors. The ones that foot the bill is the traders and the market makers that have seen their margins collapse.

As a % of profits gained from HFT, market making is small enough to not even be relevant. The more profitable strategies involve basically front running the market.

>Indeed it did. There was a flash crash in 1962 as well.

It took a YEAR for prices to rise again. That is not volatility. Or a flash crash. That is a CRASH crash.

Wanna know how long it took for prices to rise again after the flash crash? 15 minutes. THAT'S volatility. One year? Eeeeeh, not so much.

>Sure, but there are plenty of other players in the market that traditionally have been able to shave a lot more from investors.

Yes, it is not the biggest rip off the world (or indeed the equity market) has ever seen. That doesn't change anything about its fundamental nature, however.

>As for your comments that HFT is not driving down spreads, there are plenty of evidence that they do. Spreads have collapsed to nothing in the 15-20 years of operating HFTs.

Spread have declined because electronic trading reduced the transaction costs of trading.

It ought to be glaringly obvious that anything that happened 20 years ago had NOTHING to do with HFT. It didn't even exist in a limited form until 15 years ago and only really took off 5 years ago.

Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by yummyfajitas on Friday March 14, 2014 @06:26AM (#7397843)
It's about preventing HFT operators from effectively levying a tax on the rest of the participants in the equities market...HFT takes money directly from pension funds who are executing large orders, by 'skimming' off the orders they make.

Can you explain the mechanics of this "skimming" and explain how a transaction tax would prevent it? Detailed mechanics please, not vague talking points or meaningless nanex graphs.

Firstly, HFT WITHDRAWS liquidity precisely when it is needed the most. Most algos will freeze up during times of market distress.

Most algos work just fine during distress - HFTs love volatility. They are switched off during distress for regulatory reasons (broken trades).

If you buy accenture at $1 during the flash crash, sell at $40, then accenture goes up to $44, you'll find yourself with a $4 loss after the regulators break your $1 trade. That's quite a reward for helping to fix a distressed market.

Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by crdoconnor on Friday March 14, 2014 @06:35AM (#7397878)
>Can you explain the mechanics of this "skimming" and explain how a transaction tax would prevent it? Detailed mechanics please, not vague talking points or meaningless nanex graphs.

Here:

A classic aggressive strategy involves hunting and trapping “whales.” It is a good example of aggressive HFT strategy.

It is initiated by a “pinging” operation. This involves placing multiple orders designed to detect the presence of a market participant with a large position that it is in the process of accumulating or liquidating. “High frequency traders employ pattern recognition software to detect large institutional orders sitting in dark pools or other liquidity venues.”41 When it pings, the algorithmic trader places orders to buy and/or sell in an array of prices inside the bid/ask spread. If the potential target market participant starts walking through the orders, it becomes clear that a large position is in play that could consume all of the liquidity on one side of the market (bid or ask). Traders sometimes refer to the potential target as a “whale.” Often, a whale intends to buy or sell a large block for structural reasons and is relatively less sensitive to price than other buyers and sellers. If the trader’s order strategy reveals price insensitivity, the whale becomes a target.

For example, an investment fund might have experienced large redemptions from its investors that require liquidation of investments under the terms of the fund. The fund is compelled to sell promptly and is relatively insensitive to price. It is a properly motivated whale.

Once a whale is sighted and its price insensitivity is confirmed, it becomes clear that dominating the other side of the market will give the algorithmic trader control of the bid/ask pricing mechanism. In our example, the algorithmic trader would meet the offers of all of the bidders for the shares that the whale seeks to sell, becoming the sole and dominant purchaser in the marketplace. The algorithmic trader establishes a narrow band of absolute market power controlling the particular securities or derivatives that the whale seeks to buy or sell. The whale will be compelled to either abandon the market or transact at the price demanded by the algorithmic trader.

In an instant, the algorithmic trader cancels all “pinging” orders and buys the market in order to extract as much value as possible. It will also likely flood the trading venue with orders to create congestion and slow other market participants who are also watching and might intervene. The whale must transact at the price required by the algorithmic trader to accumulate or liquidate the position, as appropriate. When the transaction with the whale is accomplished, the quote stuffing orders are all cancelled.

In the final step, the algorithmic trader liquidates the position acquired from the whale immediately, but at a new bid/ask spread reestablished at market levels that are more competitive. The algorithmic trader intends that its profit from moving the bid/ask spread to take advantage of the whale’s price insensitive motivation will exceed the potential loss from the operation if the whale detects that it is being taken advantage of. For this reason, the strategy is most useful if all of the steps can be executed quickly, before detection is possible.

By displacing the entire side of a bid/ask spread, the HFT eliminates all meaningful depth of buying or selling interest for a short time period. As a result, the observed spread in the market is meaningless. Various studies that examine the narrowing of bid ask spreads in the modern marketplace miss the crucial point that HFT tactics like the one described are missing the point that the narrowing is an illusion.42 If the study draws the conclusion that HFT narrows spreads, it is simply misleading.

(From: http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2013/03/yes-virginia-hft-and-...)

N.B. Price insensitivity in this context means "not knowing" what the price should be. Not "not caring". The deleterious effect on the market should nonetheless be obvious.

Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by yummyfajitas on Friday March 14, 2014 @06:52AM (#7397927)
What you describe is predatory trading, which is a trading strategy engaged in by players at many speeds. And all you've shown is that the price impact of a whale dumping stock is now felt by the whale, not by the other players in the market.

I.e., before the big player decided to liquidate the natural price was X. After they decided to liquidate the natural price is Y < X. The market will move from X to Y, it's only a matter of when. If the whale sells at X, the other players eat the loss. If HFTs predate on the whale, the HFTs gain, other players take less of a loss, and the whale eats more of the loss.

Why is this bad? Is it somehow a desirable feature of the markets that Goldman can dump 1M shares of AAPL and the rest of us are supposed to eat the price impact?

Also, predation is unlikely to be affected by an FTT. You typically make well over 6bps from predatory strategies. It's only the low margin market making which will be affected.

Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by crdoconnor on Friday March 14, 2014 @07:31AM (#7398064)
this strategy is ineffective with the transaction tax. it should be obvious why.

the whale is normally a pension fund or some other institutional investor that doesn't have the resources of an hft. that means they get burned.

I find it somewhat amusing that you're assuming that the rest of the market needs to be protected from the pensioners by Goldman Sachs.

Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by yummyfajitas on Friday March 14, 2014 @07:44AM (#7398116)
this strategy is ineffective with the transaction tax. it should be obvious why.

Explain like I'm a 5 year old child how a 6bps tax will prevent HFTs from running a strategy generating 20-100bps of alpha. It'll certainly prevent them from running a market making strategy generating 1-2bps.

You also still haven't explained why it's better for the whale (i.e., someone large enough to move markets) to be able to make others suffer the price impact of their trades.

Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by jules on Friday March 14, 2014 @08:04AM (#7398208)
How is the whale making others suffer? If an investment fund is forced to sell because of its terms, then it's making itself suffer. It's just that now HFT traders get to serve as the useless middle man.
Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by yummyfajitas on Friday March 14, 2014 @08:24AM (#7398281)
Concrete example. The whale wants to dump 1MM shares which will result in a price drop from $105 to $100.

Currently the bid/ask is $104.9/105.1. If the whale sells at 104.9, the market will figure it out, and the counterparties who just bought will find the price of their shares drops to $100. A predator forces the whale to suffer more of the price impact while making price improvements for the counterparties.

I don't see a reason to prioritize the whale over the counterparties.

Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by jules on Friday March 14, 2014 @08:36AM (#7398324)
First, the "benefit" to the counterparties is infinitesimal. The predator is going to scape up the market at as lost cost as possible. Second, shares don't magically lose underlying value just because an investment fund is forced to sell. Longer term the price will go to whatever it would go anyway. Investors who bought did not lose that $5. Besides, even with HFT involved the short term price will still drop to $100 so everyone holding those shares still "suffers". Suffice it to say that this is a ridiculous argument which I'm sure you are not actually making but I'm just pointing this out. Third, because of shady HTF practices like flooding the exchange with orders, it's most likely actually hurting the counterparties, impeding their ability to adjust their price.

Now tell me, what social good did the HFT middle man bring?

Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by yummyfajitas on Friday March 14, 2014 @08:55AM (#7398392)
Supply goes up - price goes down. If whales weren't worried about price impact they wouldn't be hiding their offers (typically by running HFT systems of their own, or renting them) to begin with.

Third, because of shady HTF practices like flooding the exchange with orders, it's most likely actually hurting the counterparties, impeding their ability to adjust their price.

I don't understand. Counterparties want to buy and a predator is improving prices. How does this hinder them?

I'm not asserting that predation is socially good or bad. It marginally increases market efficiency and causes small players to lose less money to the big boys - that's the extent of my claims.

I just don't understand why everyone seems to think helping the big players is somehow socially beneficial. What's good for Goldman is good for America?

Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by jules on Friday March 14, 2014 @09:18AM (#7398498)
I see you ignored the fact that counterparties are actually only "benefiting" infinitesimally. Convenient.

> I don't understand. Counterparties want to buy and a predator is improving prices. How does this hinder them?

That's not what I said. It's not the offers themselves that are hurting, it's the intentional clogging up of the exchange by the HFT traders which in effect locks out everybody else.

> marginally increases market efficiency and causes small players to lose less money to the big boys

As in trades get executed a femtosecond earlier and for a infinitesimally different price, if you conveniently ignore shady practices like clogging up exchanges? Yea, that is most definitely worth the big bucks the HFT traders are making on the other side of the transaction. /s

> I just don't understand why everyone seems to think helping the big players is somehow socially beneficial. What's good for Goldman is good for America?

You pick Goldman Sachs as an example because you know people will have an emotional reaction, and ignore pension funds etc. This is an argument designed to run on people's emotions. Besides, Goldman Sachs, unlike pension funds, is perfectly capable and in fact does do HFT of its own.

Eradicating HFT is socially beneficial because it will (A) remove a bunch of wasted effort to be just a tiny bit faster than everybody else (B) remove the HFT middle man tax for investors who just want to trade with other investors.

Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by yummyfajitas on Friday March 14, 2014 @10:33AM (#7398946)
You claim the benefit is "infinitesimal" and I have no idea why or how you would claim this.

It's not the offers themselves that are hurting, it's the intentional clogging up of the exchange by the HFT traders which in effect locks out everybody else.

Exchanges don't get "clogged" except in rare cases like the facebook IPO.

Goldman Sachs, unlike pension funds, is perfectly capable and in fact does do HFT

Pension funds do run HFT in order to hide their trades. They either build it themselves or rent an algo from pipeline/etc.

Look, you clearly don't know much about the topic beyond what you read on zerohedge. I'll leave you to it.

Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by jules on Friday March 14, 2014 @10:53AM (#7399090)
> You claim the benefit is "infinitesimal" and I have no idea why or how you would claim this.

Where do we see all the genuine long term investors being happy with HFT because they benefit so much from them? That's right, they aren't.

> Exchanges don't get "clogged" except in rare cases like the facebook IPO.

Then why do HFT traders do this?

> Pension funds do run HFT in order to hide their trades. They either build it themselves or rent an algo from pipeline/etc.

Sure, as I said, either you lose to the HFT middle man, or you lose by having to invest in your own pointless infrastructure in the cat and mouse zero sum game.

Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by mmaldacker on Friday March 14, 2014 @06:23AM (#7397832)
>Secondly, they're adding trading volume, not liquidity. It was never hard to actually sell or buy a stock before HFT. They're not cutting down on spreads (that's what market makers do - and HFT is NOT market making).

Can we start distinguishing technology from strategies? HFT is the technology of inserting/amending/deleting orders extremely quickly in an exchange. There are many different financial institutions that use this with different strategies. Some are good, some are not so good. Market Makers almost all use HFT, they have to provide the best prices and update them as fast as possible when market conditions change to stay competitive. (Spacial) arbitrage is another strategy that requires HFT and is important to make markets more efficient.

> HFT is basically legalized front running.

Again, there are no relation between front running and HFT. Front running applies to brockers that use knowledge of their client's investments to make money for themselves. They might do that with or without HFT. Acting faster than a competitor on price change is not front running.

Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by crdoconnor on Friday March 14, 2014 @06:29AM (#7397849)
>Again, there are no relation between front running and HFT. >Front running applies to brockers that use knowledge of >their client's investments to make money for themselves.

And HFT operators effectively gain knowledge of the investments of the rest of the market by placing frequent, small orders (or placing an order and then canceling it).

They then use the knowledge they've gained by seeing how the market responds to their bids.

Front running the way a broker does it is illegal. The way an HFT does it legal. It's the same principle and has the same damaging effect on the markets.

Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by mmaldacker on Friday March 14, 2014 @06:43AM (#7397902)
Most exchanges have public order books (i.e. available to everyone), so the information you gain with those small orders is also gained by everyone else; that's not front running.
Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by crdoconnor on Friday March 14, 2014 @06:53AM (#7397929)
>the information you gain with those small orders is also gained by everyone else

I'm not certain how long before the information is made public (seconds if you pay? minutes if you don't...), but I'm absolutely certain it'd be too late for anybody else to make use of it.

Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by mmaldacker on Friday March 14, 2014 @07:09AM (#7397979)
It's available within microseconds/milliseconds (not including time to travel over the network to wherever you are compared to the exchange's datacentre). It's made available to everyone at the same time (again, if you have a shitty connection, you'll get the information later). You use the exact same system whether you're a bank, investor, broker, hedge fund, ... The only difference is how close you are to the datacentre, how good your networking is, how optimized your trading applications are, which protocol you're using, etc.
Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by jules on Friday March 14, 2014 @07:25AM (#7398034)
The fact that technically, the information may be available at exactly the same time to everybody doesn't make it right (and is it really, or does the guy who initiated it get the info just a bit earlier?). What's happening is that you have a whole industry spinning its wheels to be just a little bit ahead of everybody else. This is a zero sum game. Either the other traders have to build the same kind of extremely fast systems which is just money wasting, or the high frequency traders get to skim off their profit. This is of no benefit to anybody except the high frequency traders, hence why this law was invented.
Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax by yummyfajitas on Friday March 14, 2014 @07:33AM (#7398074)
Everyone who pays for DMA is on the same multicast feed.