Re:The gargantuan stupidity of the financial transactions tax
by Houshalter on Friday March 14, 2014 @06:56AM
(#7397936)
I don't think that's entirely correct. They are profiting from information asymmetry. Markets change slightly and they know it 1 millisecond before everyone else. In that millisecond they buy or sell and profit from the price change. This is stuff that would have been done anyways by regular traders. It's just the high speed traders are now faster and so do it first.
As far as I can tell that isn't hurting anyone more than normal arbitrage.
The problem with HFT is that practically speaking, the value of a company can't change in timeframes shorter than a couple of hours (barring exceptional circumstances like a big announcement). So a HFT firm is not actually benefiting from information asymmetry about the product of the company being traded or real-world conditions, it is benefiting from information asymmetry about the conditions at the exchange. In theory this is transferring money from subject-matter experts to experts in how exchange servers & the local fiberoptic grid works.
I'd be alone in a room of HF traders, but this isn't useful economic activity vs. subject matter experts making money.
I don't understand all the arguments about 'liquidity', I don't see why a slight price spread is a bad thing; provided that I can sell stock in an hour or so. There isn't a magic 'efficient price' determined by the gods of the market - it is whatever the buyer is willing to pay.