Re:Show HN: A new platform for meaningful, balanced debates
by xerophtye on Friday March 14, 2014 @01:51AM
(#7397185)
Woah! This would be so cool. So here's my tl;dr of this:
A post would include:
- Premise (a set of aximotic claims, or previous conclusions from other posts)
- A list of arguments.
The reply to this, would:
- point out which premise you disagree with
- Add new premises (which may invalidate previous arguments)
- Add new arguments based on your premises
We can also perhaps maintain a global pool of premises for that debate so when a new comer comes in, he can look at all the points raised by everyone, and taking them into account, post his or her own argument. Perhaps premises maybe remove-able from this pool if a consensus is reached that it is invalid (or perhaps when the original poster is convinced, and he or she chooses to retract it).
A post would include:
- Premise (a set of aximotic claims, or previous conclusions from other posts)
- A list of arguments.
The reply to this, would:
- point out which premise you disagree with
- Add new premises (which may invalidate previous arguments)
- Add new arguments based on your premises
We can also perhaps maintain a global pool of premises for that debate so when a new comer comes in, he can look at all the points raised by everyone, and taking them into account, post his or her own argument. Perhaps premises maybe remove-able from this pool if a consensus is reached that it is invalid (or perhaps when the original poster is convinced, and he or she chooses to retract it).
Did i get it right?