News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: A new platform for meaningful, balanced debates by itafroma on Thursday March 13, 2014 @07:03PM (#7395763)
When I look at the page now, I see a number of leading, loaded talking points that—to me—are anything but balanced:

- The Winter Olympics is inherently elitist

- seatbelt fines are a joke - people should be responsible for their own safety

- Is it fair that a family should be given $200000 because their situation made for a good news story?

- Its ok for parents to drug their children on long flights

It's understandable that a site full of user-generated content is going to have some content that's detrimental or counter to the site's goals (in this case, fostering opinions that are "aware and respectful of the other side"[1]), but I would consider curating the front page so that stuff doesn't appear front and center to color a first impression.

[1]: https://www.saysaw.org/about

Re:Show HN: A new platform for meaningful, balanced debates by ebyc1234 on Thursday March 13, 2014 @07:39PM (#7395941)
Definitely a good point itafroma. The idea is that people can post their own opinions that can be agreed or disagreed with, but you're right the homepage should be curated. I certainly don't agree with a lot of what's on there, but a good topic is one which gains interest and provokes a useful discussion.