Re:Women in Computing: The Night I was the Belle of the Ball
by MichaelDickens on Thursday March 13, 2014 @06:22PM
(#7395537)
Ah, thanks for the correction. I haven't read the article in a while and I just glanced back through it.
> Which is rather suspect, considering it appears to have been cherry-picked from amongst the seven studies the author referenced.
It's near the middle of the range, though (a bit on the high end), so it seems like a reasonable assumption.
That's not an accurate summary of the linked article's conclusions. It makes no conclusion about the percentage of accusations that are false. Rather, it takes as a seemingly arbitrary premise that 8% of accusations are false. From the article:
> Lisak lists seven studies he considers credible, which find false accusation rates of 2.1%, 2.5%, 3.0%, 5.9%, 6.8%, 8.3%, 10.3%, 10.9%....We will stick with the article’s figure of 84,000 reported rapes per year and 8% false accusation rate, for a total of 6,750 falsely accused.
The article's conclusion is actually about the chance that any particular man will be falsely accused in his lifetime. I can't say whether that particular conclusion is accurate. I can only observe that it is meaningless unless one accepts the 8% assumption. Which is rather suspect, considering it appears to have been cherry-picked from amongst the seven studies the author referenced.