Re:The $22,500 MP3: Does The Constitution Protect People Or ...
by christopherolah on Monday August 03, 2009 @10:32AM
(#739268)
Fortunately, we live in a legal system where one needs to _prove_ how much damage was done. The RIAA did not, according the the article, demonstrate anything beyond the value of the song, $0.99.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The $22,500 MP3: Does The Constitution Protect People Or ...
by michael_dorfman on Monday August 03, 2009 @10:43AM
(#739290)
So, you're arguing that the fine should be $0.99 times the number of people who downloaded each song this person shared, times some kind of multiplier for punitive damanges?
Re:The $22,500 MP3: Does The Constitution Protect People Or ...
by jacquesm on Monday August 03, 2009 @11:56AM
(#739442)
That would be something that would probably be palatable to a lot of people. It is based in fact, not in some arbitrary figure pulled out of the air.
Re:The $22,500 MP3: Does The Constitution Protect People Or ...
by joshfinnie on Monday August 03, 2009 @11:19AM
(#739363)
Well it should be even lower than $0.99. I would be shocked if Apple is making zero profit for their iTunes store. They are probably charged something like $0.75 a song per person. This should make for a good baseline for these cases.