Re:ChilledLime: A Twitter for Opinions
by eric_h on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @11:04PM
(#7389861)
I'd rather draw attention to the RFC. Sites that collect email addresses do, sometimes, reject that +suffix to the left of the @, precisely to avoid that identification. The RFC says the left of the @ is up to the host, more or less, so that's how it should be treated.
Re:ChilledLime: A Twitter for Opinions
by Centigonal on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @04:59PM
(#7388356)
I feel like this is a great learning project, but that there really isn't a niche for this kind of opining that hasn't already been filled by Twitter, Reddit, Facebook, etc.
But go ahead and prove me wrong!
On the site itself: You do a good job of explaining how to use everything, but the layout is really complex, and I don't think most users will be engaged enough to try and learn it all before being able to use the thing.
Re:ChilledLime: A Twitter for Opinions
by ISeemToBeAVerb on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @05:05PM
(#7388399)
No disrespect to you, but I'm gonna have to go with Seeless on this one. I don't see any added value to what already exists. There's really no friction to finding topic-driven conversations on Twitter. If you want to jump into a topic just search for relevant hashtags.
I applaud the effort, but I think this is an example of fixing a problem that doesn't exist. Keep trying though!
Re:ChilledLime: A Twitter for Opinions
by axx on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @07:35PM
(#7389151)
It seems, like this is the same idea that "Amen" had a few years ago: https://getamen.com/
To me this feels, like i am filling out forms with informations about my opionions, so someone can sell it (even better than twitter-like "plain text") to advertisers.
If i want to know, what my friends are thinking about product XYZ, i do exactly one thing: i ask them.
I don't want to hate on the idea, but to me it seems kinda useless.
Re:ChilledLime: A Twitter for Opinions
by briantrice on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @09:05PM
(#7389511)
You should be aware that there was a site like this in 2006 called Standpoint, partly by Gentry Underwood of Mailbox. It also allowed for structural replies and disagreements. References were also included which would point to web articles or books on Amazon, etc. They never developed a proper business model and shut it down after a year. Personally, I wanted to transform/replace blog commenting with this, but it was too big an endeavor to see through.
Re:ChilledLime: A Twitter for Opinions
by softbuilder on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @06:50PM
(#7388961)
I've seen this idea played out to its logical conclusion with a site a few years back. What happened was essentially what you see on local news websites: A small, bitchy community was created and provided no value to anyone. I'm sure there are ways to mitigate that behavior with smarter design and administration, so better luck to these guys.
Re:ChilledLime: A Twitter for Opinions
by navpatel on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @06:25PM
(#7388814)
It looks like you can upvote/downvote other's opinions. Is this being counted towards the totals? Because now you're testing how many people are willing to go through the "Supports", and upvote the ones they agree with, downvote the ones they don't
Re:ChilledLime: A Twitter for Opinions
by akos on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @06:31PM
(#7388854)
That's a thing I have been thinking about for ages.
Curently it works like this:
- Someone adds an opinion (they show their support for the viewpoint -> the viewpoint gets a +1)
- Someone votes on an opinion (they show that they like/dislike the opinion not necessarily the viewpoint -> the count stays the same)
But go ahead and prove me wrong!
On the site itself: You do a good job of explaining how to use everything, but the layout is really complex, and I don't think most users will be engaged enough to try and learn it all before being able to use the thing.
I know the market is pretty small, but I think there is potential in it. It is an interesting experiment for me.
I applaud the effort, but I think this is an example of fixing a problem that doesn't exist. Keep trying though!
To me this feels, like i am filling out forms with informations about my opionions, so someone can sell it (even better than twitter-like "plain text") to advertisers.
If i want to know, what my friends are thinking about product XYZ, i do exactly one thing: i ask them.
I don't want to hate on the idea, but to me it seems kinda useless.
I also want to thank everyone who checked it out and gave some thoughts on it.
Here are some invites for you guys: http://chilledlime.com/url/e.php?inv=80505e
Your competition is versus.com and state.com.