News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mozilla and Epic Preview Unreal Engine 4 Running in Firefox by taeric on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @03:36PM (#7387759)
And better tooling helps here more than anything else. The giant elephant in the room nobody likes to speak towards is that Flash dominated not because it was a great language, but because they had awesome tooling around it. This is doing very little to address that.

Now, the Unreal Engine is a great tool in and of itself. Having it target the browser is the questionable part to me.

Re:Mozilla and Epic Preview Unreal Engine 4 Running in Firefox by cwyers on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @05:04PM (#7388392)
If you look at the browser makers who primarily target operating systems other than their own (Safari doesn't count, as Safari for Windows is mainly a developer tool, not a product; and Opera doesn't count, as it's now based on Chrome, rather than being its own), they're pushing heavily for the browser to be the userspace, both in terms of shipping an OS based around their browsers (ChromeOS/FirefoxOS) and shipping apps to current OSes using their browsers rather than native code.

This demo may focus on the high-end graphics, but I doubt that's the reason anyone is investing effort into this. Mozilla wants cross-platform mobile games on Firefox OS, and Epic (I'm guessing) wants to be able to run games on Firefox OS/Chrome OS/Sailfish/Tizen/Ubuntu Touch/flavor-of-the-month that supports HTML 5, as a long-term hedging of bets. Not all of those explicitly support asm.js, but Chrome is going to get better at supporting asm.js even if it never gets to feature parity with Firefox, and the non-iOS world is likely to be running a derivative of Chrome or Firefox.

Re:Mozilla and Epic Preview Unreal Engine 4 Running in Firefox by taeric on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @07:59PM (#7389256)
So, if you look at the four main browser vendors... Well, two of the four browser vendors, you will find that browser vendors would like to extend the reach of the browser.

Not sure how that is surprising.

The argument for wanting to target all of the platforms seems nice. Except the major tooling companies that want to target multiple platforms have already learned how. Seeing games come out on PC, Xbox, and Playstation is proof enough of that.

So, again, what does this buy that the tooling does not already support? Especially if you simply design things such that they can be cross compiled with C.

Re:Mozilla and Epic Preview Unreal Engine 4 Running in Firefox by azakai on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @06:01PM (#7388684)
Regarding tooling, I agree Flash's tools were a huge benefit for it. The same is true for engines like UE4 and its competitors, they all focus a lot on tooling. When those engines are ported to the web, the tools are part of that.

Some tools might not just work, of course, like profiling tools or anything else that runs while the game executes on the target device, as opposed to the dev environment. But:

1. I have seen even things like profilers being ported together with the engines. Takes some porting but the result is you have the engine's normal full set of tools.

2. You have the in-browser tools as well - all modern browsers have profilers, debuggers, etc. And also they support source maps, which means they can see the original source code and not the hard-to-read compiler-output JS.

Re:Mozilla and Epic Preview Unreal Engine 4 Running in Firefox by taeric on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @06:17PM (#7388765)
Right, but it is safe to assume there will always be native targets for UE4. So, how will the web target really be a benefit? I can't imagine the DOM inspector will really be that useful in designing a 3d game. Am I wrong?
Re:Mozilla and Epic Preview Unreal Engine 4 Running in Firefox by azakai on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @06:20PM (#7388781)
The web target is mainly of benefit in getting to users, not in designing the game. For design, you would use the engine's normal tools for all targets anyhow, web included.
Re:Mozilla and Epic Preview Unreal Engine 4 Running in Firefox by taeric on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @07:46PM (#7389194)
As I said elsewhere, I only take this if you are saying "users" and meaning "developers."

I can see the point, but I see access to the tools as way more valuable than this. And with the tools, I'm curious just how many more "users" developers will truly be able to aim for. One off demos not withstanding.

Re:Mozilla and Epic Preview Unreal Engine 4 Running in Firefox by azakai on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @09:08PM (#7389520)
No, I meant users: You ship your game on the web, it reaches its users - the people playing it - directly. That's the benefit of the web.

I agree tools are important too, but the main benefit of the web is it is runs everywhere, and no one controls it.

Re:Mozilla and Epic Preview Unreal Engine 4 Running in Firefox by taeric on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @10:04PM (#7389696)
How many games are there that run from links off the web that are actually making money? (Not being an ass. I seriously want to know if there are any numbers on this.)
Re:Mozilla and Epic Preview Unreal Engine 4 Running in Firefox by azakai on Thursday March 13, 2014 @12:01AM (#7389989)
I don't have business numbers, but there are huge amounts of successful games on the web, using Flash (for example FarmVille on Facebook, etc.).

The issue of course is that Flash has many technical issues, doesn't work in all browsers/all OSes, and so forth, hence the move to do the same games in HTML5.

Re:Mozilla and Epic Preview Unreal Engine 4 Running in Firefox by Jonathan_Swift on Thursday March 13, 2014 @12:04AM (#7389996)
azakia, a Flash App once requested my permission to turn on my Mac's built-in video camera and microphone.

Funny how I was just then commanded by G-d Almighty Himself to unstall my Flash plugin.

While Flash does require permission to enable video and sound input, I am dead certain that someone with a clue could find a way to do so without actually asking permission.

It's not like those who like to hang at Websites of Ill Repute are diligent about keeping their patches up-to-date.