News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by tptacek on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @10:43AM (#7385867)
No. None of this is accurate.

Microsoft gets information about vulnerabilities from the same sources as everyone else. They outspend every other software vendor by something like 4:1 on outside software security consultants. If they are in a privileged position regarding WinAPI software vulnerabilities at all, it is a marginally privileged position. No security person working at Microsoft would tell you they were confident that outsiders weren't holding severe, exploitable vulnerabilities back.

NSA, meanwhile, is as competent at sourcing vulnerabilities as any organization on the planet. They have internal research teams that generate them that are presumably competitive with any private research team, and they apparently purchase vulnerabilities like everyone else --- not from Microsoft, but from research teams that sell vulnerabilities.

Microsoft gives pre-release information about vulnerabilities to lots of different organizations; for instance, the IDS and network security vendors get pre-release info to create signatures. This program is, IIRC, over a decade old.

NSA is a dual-role organization; it also houses the USG's center for defensive technology expertise. It is the opposite of surprising that NSA would have the same relationship with Microsoft as, say, Symantec would.

Finally, CISPA does nothing resembling what you claimed it does. CISPA is opt-in; it cannot be used to force a company to disclose anything. CISPA is about incident data, not vulnerabilities. It is already lawful to share vulnerability information with the government. The gray area in data sharing is non- anonymized incident data, which can be covered by any of 10+ different regulations that make even IP-level metadata risky to share for collaborative defense.

CISPA is an extraordinarily short bill; you can simply read it instead of taking my word for it.

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by fit2rule on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @12:14PM (#7386485)
Nothing you've uttered refutes the point - that Microsoft hand over vulnerabilities to the NSA, and delay fixing them. Read the docs.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by superuser2 on Thursday March 13, 2014 @01:12AM (#7390143)
You read the docs. http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/security/dn467918

This is a publicly disclosed, publicly available program. Implying that it's somehow a government conspiracy is lying.

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by tptacek on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @12:58PM (#7386790)
Feel free to cite the document that shows Microsoft delaying fixes for NSA.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by gregsq on Thursday March 13, 2014 @01:27AM (#7390170)
The only official response from Microsoft that I can find is in reply to a question from Bloomberg [1] on this question. Frank Shaw, lead communications for Microsoft, responded by email to the question that, according to Bloomberg, information regarding 0day or other exploits are provided to a number of government agencies as an "early start", prior to public announcement.

The original email text is unavailable as far as I can see. It of course makes perfect sense that, at least under certain circumstances, and this was the sense of limit inferable from the email, that government agencies should be given the opportunity to assess whether the item being notified about has some security implication.

The claim is made by Bloomberg, by reference to "two unnamed government officials", that Microsoft is aware that such information might be applied for reasons not primarily connected to domestic defensive security. But this is only an unsubstantiated assertion.

The number of potential exploits that are known only to Microsoft at the time of notification to those agencies would be, at a lazy guess, somewhat proportional to their exploit assessment man hours, compared to the overall exploit discovery effort. I would think that would be the much smaller proportion.

1. http://mobile.bloomberg.com/news/2013-06-14/u-s-agencies-sai...

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by fit2rule on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @04:28PM (#7388140)
Do your own homework, you know how to use Google - so go use it .. a simple query "Microsoft collaborates with NSA" turns up enough reading material .. of course, unless you don't want it to be so easy to enlighten yourself on the issue, in which case no document is going to convince you of your position.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by balthazar on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @09:44PM (#7389641)
These guys are focusing narrowly on your choice of words ("delay fixes"). It was outed by the Guardian that Microsoft actively circumvents the security of some major products (Outlook, Skype) for the NSA. The Guadrian never released the Snowden doc for Microsoft collaboration [0]. Therefore, we don't the specifics of how. We just know that Microsoft backdoors its products for the federal government without telling its customers.

"Microsoft helped the NSA to circumvent its encryption to address concerns that the agency would be unable to intercept web chats on the new Outlook.com portal;" [1]

[0] https://twitter.com/ggreenwald/status/355391355939340288

[1] http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jul/11/microsoft-nsa-c...

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by tptacek on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @10:04PM (#7389697)
No, you just introduced an entirely different concern than the one introduced by the thread. The root comment suggests that Microsoft arranges to provide NSA with vulnerabilities that they deliberately do not patch so as to maximize their value to NSA. There is no evidence that anything like this has ever happened.

Your message is a red herring; I could debate your conclusions, but what would be the point? I'm sure you've got 10 more red herrings up your sleeve.

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by balthazar on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @11:04PM (#7389860)
My message is not a red herring. I did not make any conclusions of my own for you to debate. I was trying to add context (note that I replied to fit2rule, I wasn't challenging you). I quoted the Guardian and gave the reason there is no public Snowden document on the Microsoft NSA issue. Therefore, we don't know the specifics of their collaboration/cooperation. I do not dispute what you said about delayed patches, but it is meaningless without that context.

To be fair, there is not much daylight between: 'The root comment suggests that Microsoft arranges to provide NSA with vulnerabilities that they deliberately do not patch' and what the Guardian reported about Outlook. At least to me, but I'm not a security expert. Is it not considered a 'vulnerability' if Microsoft hands over the keys so to speak?

Also on a side note, it is rude to call me out like you did. I don't have herrings up my sleeves. I don't care about internet points. I just wanted to contribute more information to the discussion.

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by tptacek on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @11:07PM (#7389866)
No, that would not be considered a "vulnerability" in the sense used on this thread.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by fit2rule on Thursday March 13, 2014 @11:58AM (#7392649)
Is the user more - or less - vulnerable to an attack? You're quite the pedant, whoever you are ..
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by tptacek on Thursday March 13, 2014 @01:05PM (#7393092)
I'll happily accept this as an admission that you don't have a source to back up your original (extraordinary) claim. Thanks.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by fit2rule on Friday March 14, 2014 @12:15PM (#7399807)
Hey, so you don't understand words. I get it. Thats quite a vulnerability you've got there.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by Phlarp on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @05:12PM (#7388441)
I love seeing Tptacek being proven wrong as much as the rest of us; but this is just weak.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by fit2rule on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @05:27PM (#7388522)
I have no idea who Tptacek is, but - is it really so hard to pay attention? Microsoft collaborates with the NSA. Its in the docs, its been news for months.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by diminoten on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @05:56PM (#7388657)
I'm a little slow, my Googling skills suck, and I've been living under a rock for... let's just say "months". Can you spoon-feed me the exact article, line, and phrase where you got this idea that Microsoft delays fixing vulnerabilities at the NSA's behest?
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by Phlarp on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @05:46PM (#7388611)
For something so obviously well known you seem to have difficulty providing evidence of your specific allegation (microsoft giving NSA advance notice of unpatched zero days.)

I don't doubt it happens, so much as I expect extraordinary claims be backed with extraordinary evidence.

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by fit2rule on Friday March 14, 2014 @02:58AM (#7397326)
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by tptacek on Friday March 14, 2014 @08:14AM (#7398254)
I don't understand. Does the way your argument work rely on people not having read the other comments on this thread? Because neither of those two articles back up the claim made about NSA and Microsoft, and both appear to describe a publicly-known documented program run by Microsoft. And, both of those points have already been made on the thread.