News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by jdminhbg on Sunday August 02, 2009 @10:06PM (#738441)
The Monty Hall problem has nothing to do with his statistics, which in any case are completely dependent on his unsupported assertions, cf.:

"If, as I suspect, rescission is targeted toward the truly bankrupting cases – the top 1%..."

"But let’s not forget that the very nature of the forms is designed to create inaccuracies"

Not to mention:

"I tend to think of traditional banking and traditional insurance as mirror images: when you take out a mortgage, you get a lump sum and make a series of payments; when you get life insurance, you make a series of payments and get a lump sum."

Which pretty much sums up the problem with the current health care debate -- almost nobody involved knows the difference between insurance and care. There's no reason middlish class people need to have things like physicians' visits and normal prescription drugs filtered through an insurance company or the government, they're completely affordable and expectable on their own. You insure unexpected, unaffordable events, like crashing your car, not oil changes.

Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by jhancock on Sunday August 02, 2009 @10:55PM (#738494)
The essential problem is that the person paying the premium is not the insurance companies "customer". The health insurance company's customer is the shareholder, not the premium payer, that has to end.

I have built software for health insurance companies. I can tell you for certain they only look at the details of a policy for rescission purposes for those policies that are costing them far more than the premium has been paying. And if you watch the congress video embedded in the blog post http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2H9ufue_1uI&eurl=http%3A%..., it makes perfectly clear that the application part of a policy is very easy to find "flaws" with retroactively if the insurance company choses.

Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by weaksauce on Sunday August 02, 2009 @11:23PM (#738527)
That is so true. The insurance companies for health care should be non-profits with set salaries for all the employees.

The reason that people buy health insurance is for exactly the reason that the insurance companies drop the insured; They cost more money than they spend.

Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by kgrin on Sunday August 02, 2009 @11:54PM (#738564)
The latter point isn't entirely true - at its core, buying insurance isn't necessarily about using more than you put in over time, but rather mitigating risks (hedging). That's not necessarily how everyone treats the current system, or for that matter how it's set up, but there's certainly a tension between the "insurance" model and the "health savings account" model (and the current system sort of tries to do both).

In terms of insurance companies being run as non-profits, let me ask two pointed (and I assure you, not-meant-to-be-trollish) questions:

1) If insurance companies should be non-profits with set salaries and so forth, why not just have the government do it at that point?

2) Two recently prominent examples of non-profits set up to further socially useful goals without actually being government agencies are Sallie Mae and Freddie Mac. Those didn't turn out so hot. How would you set up these non-profits to avoid the same sorts of problems?

Actually, I should throw in a third: does anyone know of any examples (successful or not) of a non-profit insurance entity or cooperative?

Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by weaksauce on Monday August 03, 2009 @01:22AM (#738667)
The discourse on this site is great. No need to apologize for questioning anything. Here are my answers to your questions:

1. There is a big difference between government intervention and government run organizations. Government run implies inefficiency and waste. There will always be people that game the system. I am well aware of that, but if all the government did was make it a non profit it would do a lot to mitigate against the mass profitering that is going on right now.

2. Sallie Mae no longer has any ties with the government and Freddie Mac is a government sponsored enterprise. In fact they were both set up as government sponsored enterprises when they first started. Enterprise implies an entity that is in it for the money.

As for your third question I do not know of any but it would be enlightening if someone knew of one.

Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by jwhitlark on Monday August 03, 2009 @01:34AM (#738680)
Heh. Anecdote about govt. run organizations: My wife and I, upon being told that the US Post Office only offered a service between 10 and 4, commented that that was rather inconvenient for those of us with a 9 to 5 job.

The response? "We're not here for your convenience."

Wish I could have gone to someone who was...

Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by foldr on Monday August 03, 2009 @06:42AM (#738949)
Government run implies inefficiency and waste

Not always. In fact, existing government-run healthcare systems are much more efficient than the present US system.

Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by pjkundert on Monday August 03, 2009 @10:33AM (#739271)
If by "much more efficient", you mean "lethally long waiting times for treatment, limited choice and no means to estimate competency of treatment providers", then you are correct.
Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by foldr on Monday August 03, 2009 @02:01PM (#739734)
No, I mean much cheaper with better objective health outcomes. Or are you seriously suggesting that the current US system works better than (for example) the current UK system?
Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by jhancock on Monday August 03, 2009 @02:04AM (#738707)
Perhaps a special fully transparent non-profit. You can pay employees whatever wage the market demands and with certain limits, like executive packages that have to be approved by "members" (policy holders).

As to your questions: 1 - The gov shouldn't do it because we want multiple of these entities, not just one. We need choice and competition, no single point of failure.

2 - It is common to say that extending home mortgages to higher risk groups, which Freddie played a role, was to further social goals. I simply do not buy it. Everything points to money. Extending these mortgages furthered the goals of the lenders and investment bankers and home builders as well. Look at who gave money to the politicians to make these policies happen. Hint: it was all of the above, except poor people. Yes, people who couldn't afford their homes benefited but they were not the lead players in making these policies happen.

As to your third question, companies that attempt to be more of a coop have to compete in the same market as the for-profit entities. I don't think you can solve this problem without leveling the playing field.

Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by Elepsis on Monday August 03, 2009 @01:50AM (#738692)
There are a number of cooperative health insurance companies. Group Health in Seattle is one: http://www.ghc.org/about_gh/index.jhtml
Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by anamax on Monday August 03, 2009 @12:32PM (#739534)
> The insurance companies for health care should be non-profits with set salaries for all the employees.

IIRC, Kaiser is non-profit.

If you think that you can do better, why aren't you doing it? You'll do incredible good for everyone, you'll drive the evil companies out of biz, and I'm sure that we will cut you some slack and let you get rich by whatever standard you deem appropriate.

Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by onedognight on Monday August 03, 2009 @01:02PM (#739601)
"Kaiser Permanente" is technically three separate companies that share (some) infrastructure and (some) employees.

Kaiser Foundation Health Plan Inc. is non-profit. Kaiser Foundation Hospitals is non-profit. Permanente Medical Group (the doctors) is for-profit.

Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by yummyfajitas on Monday August 03, 2009 @07:07AM (#738966)
* There's no reason middlish class people need to have things like physicians' visits and normal prescription drugs filtered through an insurance company or the government, they're completely affordable and expectable on their own.*

There is a good reason for this: tax avoidance.

"Insurance" (against everything) is paid for with pre-tax dollars. Doctor visits are paid for with post-tax dollars (ignoring HSA's, etc).

If car insurance got the same tax benefits, then car insurance which pays for gas would probably be available.

Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by kgrin on Sunday August 02, 2009 @10:15PM (#738454)
That's true, though if you're on the hook for a person's catastrophic care, you may very well want to give them economic incentives (i.e. cheap/free doctor's checkups) to invest in preventative care.

Now, this doesn't mean that we ought to necessarily have a big, bad program (government or private) control everything.

But it does mean that the "insurance is for catastrophes, everything else should be out-of-pocket" model isn't necessarily as simple and wonderful as it sounds.

Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by Empact on Sunday August 02, 2009 @11:36PM (#738536)
It's actually quite common for High-Deductible plans to include payment for standard preventative care (e.g. annual physical). After all the costs covered are predictable and well-contained anyway (typically a few hundred a year).

Beyond that, the emerging "direct Primary Care" model (e.g. http://qliance.com/) is another way to remove the financial disincentive to use preventative care. With them you get unlimited around-the-clock primary care for $50+/month, so there's no additional cost to come in for a checkup. And the barriers to interacting with them are even lower than an insurance-bound doctor, as they embrace modern forms of communication so you can e-mail them about problems which otherwise would not have risen to the level of motivating an appointment.

Note that in this case, subscribers would then favor insurance which does not cover preventative care, or else they'd be paying for it twice, so it's not necessarily beneficial that all people get this support from their insurance.

Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by jdminhbg on Sunday August 02, 2009 @10:20PM (#738462)
That's true if the assumptions behind it are true -- that cheap/free doctor's checkups result in lower catastrophic care costs. I'm not aware of any study that shows that they are.
Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by kgrin on Sunday August 02, 2009 @10:24PM (#738469)
I don't have the studies in front of me, but it generally depends. In the case of diabetes, for instance, a lifetime of diet monitoring and counseling by a doctor or nurse is still way cheaper than insulin or amputation.
Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by jdminhbg on Sunday August 02, 2009 @10:40PM (#738485)
The diabetes example is not one I had thought of, I'll look into it.

What bothers me is that I see a lot of knee-jerk "we'll just make it up on preventative care" in the debate, without any way of proving how the costs add up.

Without having looked into it deeper, my question about diabetes would be whether free/cheap checkups and counseling affect the number of people who correctly handle their problem.

Re:Lies, Maths, And Health Insurance by kgrin on Sunday August 02, 2009 @11:18PM (#738521)
There's a pretty clear medical consensus (based on tons of data) that diet and exercise affects the development or progression of diabetes (well, type II). There's also a wide consensus that professional counseling and monitoring helps (though I believe it's harder to get really "clean" studies to support this, since you'd need a control group of people who you monitor closely enough to get good comparison data without actually talking to them about what's going on).

The follow-up question, of course, is whether (or how much) the cost of checkups/counseling affects whether/how much people seek it out, or whether that behavior is more idiosyncratic (i.e. "some people just don't care about their health, so even if checkups were free they wouldn't bother").

To be fair, I haven't seen any study that conclusively proves the issue (which of course doesn't imply that one isn't out there). However, if we're really going to make the claim that economic incentives don't matter, then we really need to question a lot of other assumptions as well. I'm pretty comfortable saying that at least on some level, to some degree, economic incentives have some impact on people's behavior in seeking care.

In terms of "we'll just make it up on preventative care", I agree, that's not a panacea. At the same time, a lot of the money that's slated to be spent on covering the uninsured is still spent today, just in really stupidly inefficient ways.

For instance, because you generally can't be denied emergency room care, people without insurance often end up using ERs as primary care. Because ERs are primarily meant to handle, well, emergencies, the standard of care is generally more expensive than a clinic or "regular doctor" (this means things like faster and more expensive tests, drugs, and so forth). Many of those people simply can't pay, but the hospital treated them anyway (which, just to be clear, is a GOOD thing - it would be a pretty horrid society where we let people bleed to death or what have you). Many hospitals would have a hard time staying open if this went on indefinitely, so the government reimburses them for this uninsured care.

So, at the end of the day "we the taxpayers" still pay for a good deal of uninsured care... we just do it via an indirect subsidy to hospitals for expensive ER care, rather than paying directly for (much cheaper) clinic care, or something along those lines. As with most things, the less directly we're tackling the problem, the more inefficiency there is in the system.

It would be foolish to claim that all the costs of a big health care/health insurance overhaul would be paid for by money already in the system - clearly, that depends a great deal on the details. But at the same time, it's important to remember that some of the money can come from within the system: at a minimum, if we reduce the number of uninsured people, we can reduce payments to hospitals for uninsured care.

It's not a zero-sum game - electronic medical records and that sort of stuff aside, there's a lot of honest-to-goodness inefficiency and perverse incentives in the system, and that's what (a good) reform ought to tackle.

Edit: just to be clear, reimbursements for uninsured care take many forms, and there's another, more obvious one: higher prices for everybody else. The salient point is that much of this care is being provided anyway, so why not do it more efficiently?