News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Feinstein Publicly Accuses C.I.A. of Spying on Congress by vidarh on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @09:08PM (#7383340)
Feinstein generally disgusts me, but I don't see how she's being hypocritical here.

While I disagree with her point of view on intelligence services, there's nothing hypocritical if she holds the view that their wide remits are important and necessary while still believing that explicitly violating the legal remit of their spying (CIA is explicitly forbidden from engaging in most domestic spying) and spying on the group tasked with the oversight of their spying is one step too far.

If she genuinely believes the intelligence committee is exercising real and important oversight, but that the agencies generally do the right thing, then her reaction makes total sense: Her trust has been utterly betrayed. That's what her speech sounds like - someone like Feinstein openly accusing the CIA of committing crimes is pretty spectacular.

Most of us probably just didn't expect to find out where she'd draw the line. And presumably the CIA didn't either. In that respect this might prove to be a massive misstep for them unless they do masterful damage control, since you're right - she's been one of their staunchest advocates.

She's also powerful, and a hard nail; if she's not satisfied with the way they respond to this, they might very well find they've found a foe they really don't need, as she's one of very few legislators who has a realistic shot of clipping their wings if she decides she needs to.

I don't expect her to fully see the light, but she could make a huge difference even if she gets disillusioned enough with the agencies to simply stop putting spanners in the wheels when other lawmakers tries to make the intelligence agencies more accountable.

Re:Feinstein Publicly Accuses C.I.A. of Spying on Congress by argumentum on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @10:36PM (#7383603)
The charge of hypocrisy rises due to her change of attitude when she is herself the victim of unlawful surveillance.

Keep in mind that the NSA's surveillance has already been ruled unlawful by both courts and committees appointed by the government that supervises the NSA.

So in both cases, "legal remit" was violated. She only feels this violation when it comes to herself.

We call this hypocrisy.

Re:Feinstein Publicly Accuses C.I.A. of Spying on Congress by vidarh on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @06:00AM (#7384782)
I don't agree that it is a change of attitude. That's the point. Unless you can point to her excusing previous instances of surveillance of the intelligence committee, there's no basis for the claim of hypocrisy. It's perfectly possible she is, but her statements so far does not appear to provide any evidence of it.

She can consider the intelligence committee to be in a special position on the basis of its oversight responsibility: Even if every other person on the planet is fair game, she can still hold that the CIA has gone to far when conducting surveillance against the intelligence committee without being hypocritical just on the basis of a belief that it violates the ability of Congress to carry out its mandated oversight role. The arguments she has made about separation of powers etc. are all in line with a line of thinking that makes this a special case.

Re:Feinstein Publicly Accuses C.I.A. of Spying on Congress by argumentum on Thursday March 13, 2014 @08:46AM (#7391386)
You can very easily replace "intelligence committee" in your comment with "herself" without interrupting your logic one bit.

> She can consider herself (the intelligence committee) to be in a special position on the basis of her own (its) oversight responsibility ..

I.e. you're not really saying much of anything.