News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Incubators are Bullshit by pg on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @01:46AM (#7377654)
I don't know about the others, but this is not a description of YC. The whole point of YC is to focus on real work. The first thing we tell the startups we accept is that they should build stuff and talk to users (and exercise and spend time with their families) and nothing else.

When the Airbnbs came to speak at the last dinner, Brian Chesky said that the 3 months of YC had been the most productive time in their lives.

Re:Incubators are Bullshit by cardmagic on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @01:51AM (#7377676)
I agree Paul: YC is the only incubator I would explicitly exclude from this tirade. In fact, I call out YC in section 4 as having incubated companies I would love to be like.
Re:Incubators are Bullshit by ixmatus on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @06:53AM (#7378461)
I would exclude Techstars too, I went through the Austin program and it was also one of the best things I ever did. I learned so much.

TS does have a slightly different focus than YC - first month they tell you to not build a whole lot of stuff but to talk to 90+ mentors (that they curate), then second and third months are balls-to-the-wall build, talk to customers, etc... with the third month having a focus on pitch practice for the CEO.

Re:Incubators are Bullshit by solve on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @07:50AM (#7378659)
Am I the only one who doesn't much like the word "mentor"? It makes me imagine kind of a superior/inferior relation, as if the best people aren't the ones who starting the startups. Shouldn't the very best people be the ones in the startups?

mentor:

- an experienced person in a company, college, or school who trains and counsels new employees or students.

- advise or train (someone, esp. a younger colleague).

The word has very clear, strong connotations.

So what is being said here? That founders can't be experienced serial entrepreneurs? That older people should be training younger people? It's a very strange word to choose, and I think it impacts how people perceive their roles.

Re:Incubators are Bullshit by ixmatus on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @10:22AM (#7379317)
Your interpretation, I think, is off. The mentors I met ranged from intellectually superior, experientially superior (billion dollar companies under their belt, > 1 company), financially superior, operationally superior (in ability to speak or lead or execute), etc...

Some were my age, a few were younger, some were old, and others in their 30's.

Some "mentors" were more like peers - current founders that had grown beyond the "we are trying to make it" phase. Others were aloof. Some only cared about "being a mentor for Techstars" and not actually helping the companies. Others had little to provide except for enormous enthusiasm for what everyone was doing and hung out all the time.

I learned a select few things from our mentors that was really important (mostly about leadership and fundraising) and most of the other mentors were more of a sounding board that allowed me to hone in on a consistent, concise, and powerful story about my company and our product (which we really didn't have prior).

In one meeting you'll get lots of support for direction X and then the next meeting you could be met with a lot of skepticism for that same direction X. I learned quickly that absorbing the mentor's personal experience and then training a better story by telling it and observing how much of it they understand or don't understand or is picked apart by them.

What is being said here is that founding a company is hard. Having a sounding board is extremely important as an indirect heuristic and there are some things you can directly learn from some of the mentors.

Re:Incubators are Bullshit by solve on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @11:02AM (#7379581)
No interpretation, I just pasted the Google definition.

I see, so these accelerators are talking more about "specialized experts" (the mentors) vs "generalists" (the startup founders)?

Re:Incubators are Bullshit by kohanz on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @08:29AM (#7378808)
Mentorship isn't about being the best. It's about having teachable experience.
Re:Incubators are Bullshit by simonebrunozzi on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @11:20AM (#7379718)
Exactly true.
Re:Incubators are Bullshit by michaelmior on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @08:37AM (#7378842)
I've never thought of a mentor as being necessarily superior. But if the "best" people are the ones starting the startups (which isn't always the case), they should be smart enough to know they can learn from others.
Re:Incubators are Bullshit by eru on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @11:26PM (#7383727)
Wise people can learn from fools. The opposite is not true.
[deleted]
Re:Incubators are Bullshit by michaelmior on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @09:27AM (#7379040)
I don't see how that contradicts with my statement.
Re:Incubators are Bullshit by IndieDevClub on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @10:00AM (#7379210)
When I went to tech meetups I met a couple mentors that had office hours... the first thing they started talking about was how much money they helped startups raise. They acted as if that validates any advice they gave. And their advice didn't seem that good.

In reality I got more helpful advice from my peers. That's why I recently started a club for developers. The idea is to meet weekly online and talk to each other about the progress of our projects and startups. If any developers feel like they have no network at all (like me), then you should join my club. The link is in my profile.

Re:Incubators are Bullshit by simonebrunozzi on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @11:20AM (#7379715)
The Austin program has a great star: Jason Seats. I used to mentor for him at TechStars San Antonio, and I liked him so much that when he moved to Austin, I decided to mentor for him there. Amazing guy.
Re:Incubators are Bullshit by vyala on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @07:45AM (#7378639)
I like that exercise and spend time with family part, emotional drain is cause for productivity lost, bad decisions. The basic definition of start up is to get it running, building everything all along, customers, product, technology, architecture, user experience, UI Design, re-iterate the learning and fine tune again and again. Mentor is not needed for technology advise or adding business value or evaluating user interface, instead a mentor helps to drive the startup crazy, throw the founders into kickboxing stage, let them fight and learn than learn and fight.
Re:Incubators are Bullshit by girvo on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @01:58AM (#7377696)
Yeah, thankfully the article calls YC out as being the exception.
Re:Incubators are Bullshit by valvoja on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @04:21AM (#7378011)
I'm going through a great Irish incubator at the moment and I agree. The ones that focus on customer development and give you the added resources to do it more effectively are definitely worthwhile and make your limited time more productive.

There are a lot of incubators out there. For startup founders I suggest you do your homework.

Re:Incubators are Bullshit by jn on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @04:44AM (#7378072)
Mind sharing which incubator that is?
Re:Incubators are Bullshit by valvoja on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @05:48AM (#7378261)
NDRC LaunchPad.
Re:Incubators are Bullshit by janson0 on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @02:19AM (#7377744)
It is great that you emphasize that. Success (or at least progress) seems to come down to what the founders choose to spend their time doing and/or be distracted by.

It is really easy to let meetings distract you from building.

Re:Incubators are Bullshit by ixmatus on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @07:10AM (#7378514)
Early stage, more than just meetings distract you. Hiring developers so you can expand is distracting, fundraising and being in the loop with your CEO is distracting, family and friends are distracting, coffee with brilliant and experienced people is distracting.

There comes a time when you've done this startup thing more than once, as a founder, to realize that everything - even day-to-day operations - is a distraction from the core intention of building a product. What do you do about it? Get really good at time boxing, delegating, and prioritizing.

Programmers are typically not very good at handling multi-faceted schedules and being ruthless about that schedule.

Re:Incubators are Bullshit by simonebrunozzi on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @11:19AM (#7379708)
Paul, YC is a very notable exception. You are on a league of your own, and the article acknowledges that. I also happen to agree. :)
Re:Incubators are Bullshit by davyjones on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @04:45AM (#7378074)
I have always assumed that incubator is a university setting while accelerator is an industry setting. Is this not true?
Re:Incubators are Bullshit by carrollgt91 on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @10:05AM (#7379234)
I don't think it's a description of many of the top incubators.

As a graduate of the Jumpstart Foundry in Nashville, TN, I can't say how useful a summer of paid entrepreneurial focus and education changed my life.

Also, the alumni support is fantastic. I know YC takes care of it's grads well, and JSF is definitely the same way.

Re:Incubators are Bullshit by airnomad on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @05:47AM (#7378257)
How much of _your_ one on one time can you promise to a founder if her startup get accepted to YC?