News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Maps accused of unfair competition in France(for b... by jacquesm on Sunday August 02, 2009 @11:12AM (#737504)
"The French company provides the same services for a fee and claims the Google strategy is aimed at undercutting competitors by temporarily swallowing the full cost until it gains control of the market."

That's going to be a tough one to prove, if that really is their assertion in the court documents they've basically killed themselves before it even gets started. Google has a track record of NOT charging for any of their services, why google maps - and then specifically for France - would be any different difficult to argue for.

The judge can now simply say, ok, let's wait until that happens, then you can claim your damages.

And in defense google could simply promise solemnly that they will never charge French users for access to google maps. (which I assume is their intention any way).

It's not illegal in France to allow access to a free service. Tough to compete with free. Adapt or die.

Re:Google Maps accused of unfair competition in France(for b... by jhancock on Sunday August 02, 2009 @01:42PM (#737750)
I like free services as well as the rest of us. But Google is making money indirectly off all/most of its free services. They certainly aren't creating great products for us out of kindness. There isn't an easy answer here. The free services are great, I wouldn't want to see them go away. But they are a component of anticompetitive measures into the market.

Saying adapt or die simply isn't an acceptable answer here. If you have a great map product but do not own an ecosystem of other products, such as Google has, you are on the short end of things and the market becomes smaller and less competitive.

Re:Google Maps accused of unfair competition in France(for b... by jacquesm on Sunday August 02, 2009 @02:16PM (#737821)
Absolutely. But let's contrast that with a topic that quite a few of us here have probably come up against at some point in the past: I used to sell software, license based. When the open source revolution happened there was not one free competitor for the kind of software that I was writing, there were many. The quality wasn't there, the features were not up to spec but the basic functionality was there so overnight my market dried up.

I could have gone and sued the pants of whoever was 'destroying my market', but instead I adapted and found new ways to monetize my skills.

Google has a method, and you've correctly identified it as indirectly making money off a service and that is a principle that is out in the open.

The same with newspapers that suddenly found themselves faced with free competitors and then on top of that had tons of online competition, also for free.

Nobody has a 'right' to their businessmodel, whether you have a great product or not does not enter into the equation, the marketplace is constantly shifting and you have to be prepared for such shifts.

Re:Google Maps accused of unfair competition in France(for b... by jhancock on Sunday August 02, 2009 @08:32PM (#738340)
Good points. I have had my market destroyed in a similar fashion to what you describe. I also did not think it was the right course to sue my new competitors that were giving away their product. But if the French want to have more strict and protectionist controls, so be it, its their economy. It will be interesting to see how such lawsuits pan out.
Re:Google Maps accused of unfair competition in France(for b... by viraptor on Sunday August 02, 2009 @11:29AM (#737537)
> And in defense google could simply promise solemnly that they will never charge French users for access to google maps.

They can't start charging for it easily. They would have to agree on "going commercial" with MS - otherwise everyone would just jump over to the competitor. And both MS and Google pulling free maps at the same time would be something that lawyers would like to look into... ;)

Re:Google Maps accused of unfair competition in France(for b... by jacquesm on Sunday August 02, 2009 @11:31AM (#737540)
Exactly. I really don't think this will fly. They are free to try though, you can sue anybody for anything as tumult already noted above, even when you're only telling all of your current customers that there is a free alternative that they may not even be aware of. Well done :)
Re:Google Maps accused of unfair competition in France(for b... by TriinT on Sunday August 02, 2009 @03:28PM (#737944)
A new kind of business plan:

- start a company in France providing a service that Google provides for free.

- sue Google for predatory pricing. Bonus points for added drama: make sure you point out that Google is out to destroy French jobs and undermine French culture and language.

- make money off the lawsuits, not the services the company is supposed to provide.

Do you think it could work?