News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Hardware Revolution by cottonseed on Monday March 10, 2014 @11:37AM (#7373511)
While low-cost SoC computers are great, as are tutorials about wiring up sensors and motors to your Arduino board, I think this article misses the point about the "hardware reovlution". At one point, he says:

> have the correct tools (most of which are not free)

One of the reasons the free software movement is so exciting is because it put professional quality software development tools into the hands of ... well, everyone, and let them unleash their creativity. This is why Stallman started with emacs, gcc, gdb, and the unix tools. A whole generation of programmers grew up using tools that a generation earlier would have been prohibitively expensive or inaccessible. The frameworks, tools and libraries the OP is so excited about are the continued product of that movement. They are free (as in beer) and, more importantly, free as in speech.

However, this hasn't happened to hardware development tools yet, except for a few exceptions. It might be starting. (I have my pessimistic days and my optimistic ones.) There are two classes of tools: software design tools (and firmware for hardware tools) and hardware tools themselves. Of course, we can't expect hardware tools to be free as in beer, but we can aspire to make them free as in speech. Kicad (a free PCB design tool) is light years behind the industry standard Altium. Free versions of tools for high-speed design, signal integrity analysis, etc. are basically unheard of. The on exception might be Spice, the circuit simulator. There are free designs for primitive hardware tools (e.g., power supplies, precision DMMs, oscilloscopes, logic analyzers), but they are nowhere near entry-level professional offerings, and many, even tho they call themselves "open", don't make design files available.

http://www.phenoptix.com/blogs/news/12550621-testing-the-ten...

Forget about RF-level stuff like RF signal generators and signal analyzers. I've never seen a high speed memory bus designed with open tools, for example, and I don't see how you'd ever debug it.

This is where I think the action is. A suit of open tools (software and hardware) that benefited from community improvement would truely be transformative. It would create an enormous amount of social value. I can see why it hasn't been done yet. Building open versions of these tools would require a huge amount of work, and they are incredibly valuable, so whoever does it would have to forgo a huge amount of value.

I'm finishing up something else in the short term, but I've been thinking about this a lot. I'd love to work on this problem, but it isn't at all clear to me how to fund it.

Re:The Hardware Revolution by cushychicken on Monday March 10, 2014 @11:44AM (#7373565)
I've never used Altium, but my opinion of most EE CAD software is pretty low. Unintuitive, proprietary, a pain in the ass to configure, and capping it all, usually ugly. (I primarily use Cadence, however, so there might be something great out there I don't know about.) I think now's a time for a radical re-imagining of EE CAD software. I just don't know how you would do it. :D
Re:The Hardware Revolution by swamp40 on Monday March 10, 2014 @01:57PM (#7374536)
I use Altium every day for board layouts and schematics.

It is a fantastic software package - worth every penny, and easily affordable to small-to-medium businesses.

I'll bet they have 100+ programmers constantly improving their product. Every version is more powerful and easier to use.

No way for a small startup to compete with that without charging a similar amount. And even then, Altium has a 20 year head-start.

Re:The Hardware Revolution by cottonseed on Monday March 10, 2014 @02:21PM (#7374710)
Well, I'm not thinking about a startup, but open source projects. You could have said the same thing about any of the commercial unix vendors in the early 90s -- they had a 15 year head start, hundreds of programmers, etc. And look where we are now. What could things look like in 20 years?
Re:The Hardware Revolution by sliverstorm on Monday March 10, 2014 @02:39PM (#7374830)
One of the big challenges as I see it with EDA tools- the target moves quickly. In silicon development, for example, suddenly all your customers want double-patterning support in your tools as they move to today's tiny process nodes. [0] Or, perhaps, your customers now need layer-aware optimization, again for recent processes. [1] You have to accommodate this very quickly. An ASIC program runs for a year or three, so your EDA tools need to add & mature these new features in a very short timeframe. (Well, the feature doesn't have to be mature right away, but it does have to work) This means it's a hard environment to compete in. You could develop an open-source offering to compete, but without very significant resources your tools will always be missing support for modern processes.

[0]: http://www.techdesignforums.com/practice/guides/double-patte...

[1]: http://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1279842

On a completely separate angle, compiling & optimization is basically the biggest Packing Problem you've ever faced, with several dimensions of "packing". You need some very smart people to hope to produce good results. But I've written enough for now.

Re:The Hardware Revolution by cottonseed on Monday March 10, 2014 @04:29PM (#7375496)
I agree that's true for chip design tools, but I was mostly thinking board-level design and above. Although I think there is opportunity in chip design for higher level tools not tied to chip design. To things spring to mind. After the Pentium fdiv bug, Intel hired the author of the HOL Light theorem prover. He formalized the FPU of a later chip. I'm also thinking of high-level synthesis tools like Arvind's Bluespec.
Re:The Hardware Revolution by bsder on Monday March 10, 2014 @07:07PM (#7376293)
The problem with EDA software is that, to a first approximation, the number of users of EDA software is zero.

This is why EDA software sucks so badly. The bug discovery rate is abysmal. Couple this with the fact that the number of EDA programmers is even closer to zero, and you have a recipe for a horrible industry.

Re:The Hardware Revolution by pmorici on Monday March 10, 2014 @01:49PM (#7374469)
Check out fritzing it is open source and geared toward the beginner arduino crowd with some polish it could be top notch. It seems to have a lot of traction with the adafruit/sparkfun crowd.

Eagle CadSoft is also popular with that demographic.

Re:The Hardware Revolution by benbojangles on Monday March 10, 2014 @07:13PM (#7376322)
I like Fritzing, I felt I picked it up quickly enough not to bother me. But It needs someone to update it with the latest sensors releases, or it's a case of just going through the time consuming motions of creating your own instances over and over. Anyway, I like it. I think it can be improved.
Re:The Hardware Revolution by zakhomuth on Monday March 10, 2014 @07:38PM (#7376440)
Its a babystep compared to whats needed, but we're trying to rethink EDA at upverter.com. Its a full editor thats also collaborative with lots of community features. It might be what you're looking for.
Re:The Hardware Revolution by bananas on Monday March 10, 2014 @12:22PM (#7373816)
Cadence is a fine example of how horrible it can be. Its even worse going back in time to when I had to use it on a Sun Ultra 1 with Motif UI. Everything is better now.
Re:The Hardware Revolution by cottonseed on Monday March 10, 2014 @12:53PM (#7374049)
I don't either. I'm not even an EE. I figure someone deeply embedded in the current set of tools would be best positions to see where to go next.
Re:The Hardware Revolution by noobiemcfoob on Monday March 10, 2014 @12:13PM (#7373757)
In response to cushychicken, The CE software isn't much better. Half the time, I can't figure out why companies pay for the licenses. The other half, I marvel at just how much the software does for you.

But the tools aside, without a low cost foundry and with a low barrier to entry for new developers (i.e. not requiring a lengthy approval process), the open source tools are just a first step. It would be amazing to one day have the resources for a hobbyist to build an ASIC. Once we've reached the limits Moore's law, that may be the only way to keep the IC industry interesting.

Re:The Hardware Revolution by cottonseed on Monday March 10, 2014 @12:26PM (#7373862)
I wasn't even thinking about silicon-level design, just board-level design. You could get pretty far with great board design tools and medium-sized FPGAs.
Re:The Hardware Revolution by cottonseed on Monday March 10, 2014 @12:51PM (#7374031)
OK, actually, I was: I'd love to see a free version of Synopsys design compiler. I agree, tho, NDAs for FPGA vendors and foundries is a huge problem.
Re:The Hardware Revolution by mng2 on Monday March 10, 2014 @05:22PM (#7375771)
This fellow[0] designed a DDR2 interface, but I don't think he ever reported back whether or not it worked. Apparently he did it by hand in Eagle!

To address your point about tools, I think you're right about the value aspect -- good tools cost money. But then again, does the average hobbyist need those kinds of tools? How much demand is there for, say, a 100 MHz open 'scope that costs a bit more than a Rigol? Ham enthusiasts would probably rather trade around old HP/Tek equipment.

I do agree in principle that there should be something like the Global Village Construction Set, for electronics. But it would be a monumental undertaking.

[0]: http://danstrother.com/2011/01/16/spartan-6-bga-test-board/

Re:The Hardware Revolution by cottonseed on Monday March 10, 2014 @06:42PM (#7376169)
Yeah, I've seen that. I guessed he didn't report back because it didn't work, but who knows.

Good question. I agree, that's probably the first step: a more expensive inferior product, but I'm trying to look beyond that. If the open tools compete in features, and the manufacturers don't have to recoup design investment, shouldn't the open tools be cheaper? I want to live in a world where people have access to tools at the marginal cost of manufacturer. Once the open tools can compete on features, presumably volume would increase, making them competitive.

Rigol, like the bigger test equipment manufactures, sell heavily software limited equipment and charge handsomely for upgrades. Dave on the EEVBlog recently did a teardown of the newly released Tek MDO3000 6-in-1 scope. The entry level box costs ~$3,000. It costs about $15K for all the features enabled. Same hardware. Dave estimated the signal analyzer front end costs $40 in raw parts but $2,500 to enable. What's the real costs of the box? I'm not saying open is necessarily cheaper, but I'm not yet convinced it couldn't be.