Re:After Big Bet, Hedge Fund Pulls the Levers of Power
by kkowalczyk on Monday March 10, 2014 @11:02AM
(#7373278)
Acman's behavior is not bad because he's shorting Herbalife.
It's bad because after he bought short position, he's using his money and influence to crash Herbalife, by any means necessary, buying fake concern from various "community" groups, trying to influence government officials to start investigation etc.
Metaphorically speaking, he's a corporate terrorist, trying to cause distress in a company in order to profit from it.
And let's be clear: he doesn't care what happens after (potentially temporary) drop in Heralife's stock price.
He's end-game is not fixing Herbalife via some government action, all he needs to make his billions is temporary drop in stock price caused by FUD that an investigation would create.
If someone wanted to actually put this into practice, the thing to do would be to create a fund and identify several companies doing illegal things, short the stocks, and then launch campaigns against them.
I'm not sure if the math works out though. With traditional VC your wins are orders of magnitude larger than your losses, which is what allows the portfolio to succeed. I don't know enough about shorts to know whether a similar structure could be created.