Edit: incidentally, this keyboard, despite being fairly new, only gets 5 or 6 keys on the rollover test at the top of the article
For one, I type far too quickly for auditory feedback to be of any meaningful use. Second, a combination muscle memory and spring feedback usually catch situations where I've missed a key (I can feel that I hit it too lightly). Third, I find some of the mechanical keyboards to be too stiff and require more force to fully press each key, leaving my arms more fatigued at the end of the day.
I suppose it's individual preference, but the soft clicking I get from my laptop or Microsoft ergo keyboard (low-travel laptop style keys) are more than enough for me.
To add to your list of keyboard gripes though:
- Keys with sloped sides (an extension of "keytops too close together") that cause me to hit adjacent keys when I slightly miss
- "Fn" and Ctrl keys swapped. I was working with keyboard in a seldom-used office yesterday that caused me to repeatedly clear lines when I meant to hit Ctrl+C. I will be replacing that hunk o' junk.
- Absolutely no separation between Function keys and numeric keys.
Keyboards in the last few years have had:
- Mushy key feel. I can't tell when I've actually done a keystroke.
- Keys that are hard to strike (need to press on them just right, or they hang up or don't register). This is particularly bad on the wider keys.
- Keytops too close together; I mash multiple keys.
- Embarrassingly bad features: Function-key lock is the classic one here. Let's not talk about the 'diamond' arrow keys that have occasionally appeared.
I'd buy half a dozen "Natural" keyboards with decent Cherry hardware running the show, ESC in the right spot, and no wacky features. I don't even need a numeric keypad. I'd pay more money for some remapping (though just about any 20 cent microcontroller will have enough EEPROM to do this).
Whaddya say, Microsoft? Care to make a good keyboard again?