Re:FCC Takes On Apple And AT&T Over Google Voice Rejection
by scott_s on Friday July 31, 2009 @09:12PM
(#735805)
I see no reason why Apple and AT&T - who are corporations, not people - should have the right to do as they please. Our government grants corporations the ability to exist because doing so is beneficial to society. If a corporation is doing something that is harmful to consumers - and potentially society as a whole - then I want the government to step in.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:FCC Takes On Apple And AT&T Over Google Voice Rejection
by tc on Friday July 31, 2009 @10:08PM
(#735875)
Corporations are just collections of people (except for the grant of limited liability, which is really an abuse).
Too often, I think, we judge 'harmful' by the impossible standard of "could I imagine things being better if I could force others to do things exactly my way" rather than "would we be better off if they didn't exist at all."
So that is to say, sure, if a company is actually causing a harm, in the legal sense of the word (committing fraud, breaking contracts, etc.), then they should have to pay restitution for that. That's what the law is for. Not to second-guess how companies could better serve their customers.