News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Meeting Satoshi by samfisher83 on Thursday March 06, 2014 @12:10PM (#7355007)
Eventually the government is going to come after him. If you just happen to be sitting on 400 million without paying taxes the government is going to be interested.
Re:Tell HN: Meeting Satoshi by tzs on Thursday March 06, 2014 @04:12PM (#7356621)
It is not at all clear that mining and sitting on Bitcoin causes any tax liability. The tax liability might only come when the Bitcoin is exchanged or spent.

For instance, if I take a piece of paper and some paint, and use them to make a painting that I hang on my wall, and this painting would sell for $100k if I elected to sell it, I do not have to report $100k of income. I only have taxable income when I actually sell the painting.

Re:Tell HN: Meeting Satoshi by tlrobinson on Thursday March 06, 2014 @03:08PM (#7356241)
Re:Tell HN: Meeting Satoshi by javert on Thursday March 06, 2014 @02:02PM (#7355818)
That simply isn't true. As someone else said, taxes are not owed on bitcoin until you realize your profit by converting them to USD or spending them on goods.
Re:Tell HN: Meeting Satoshi by danudey on Thursday March 06, 2014 @02:44PM (#7356095)
Because really, things don't have value until they're sold. Until then, there's just assumed value.

He might have $400m worth of bitcoins, but can he actually sell them and get $400m for them? It would be tricky.

Re:Tell HN: Meeting Satoshi by JanezStupar on Thursday March 06, 2014 @12:53PM (#7355337)
What would be the exact time he would owe them? I mean at what price?

When he mined them and they were worthless? When he sells them?

I think he either owes couple of cents or nothing.

Re:Tell HN: Meeting Satoshi by g4m8i7 on Thursday March 06, 2014 @01:03PM (#7355414)
You usually pay for this sort of thing based on profit, more or less.

In this case, his basis is $0 (his cost to acquire the asset). Were he to sell all of them, his profit is essentially 100%; however, I'm not entirely sure how bitcoin gains are codified. If they're regular capital gains, then it's done around that cost basis ($0 in this case), but if they aren't, then I don't know.

Re:Tell HN: Meeting Satoshi by ufmace on Thursday March 06, 2014 @01:30PM (#7355614)
There was a good post on the tax implications of Bitcoin by (what I think was) an actual accountant a while back. The gist is that it's taxable only when converted to real goods. So if he mined some number of coins early on and is just holding them in wallets, then he owes nothing. Any time anybody sells any coins for cash or any other real goods, they owe tax on the difference between the sale price and the original purchase price.

There hasn't been much formal on "purchase price" of mined coins as far as I know/remember. It's probably safest to treat them as a purchase price of zero, thus if you sell mined coins for $100, then you have a $100 income that you owe tax on. A clever accountant might be able to claim that mining hardware, electricity, etc, is the cost of acquisition, and so offset the sale price in that way, but it probably isn't worth the trouble for Satoshi or anyone else mining in the early days.

Re:Tell HN: Meeting Satoshi by PaulAJ on Thursday March 06, 2014 @02:54PM (#7356151)
As I understand it, if you are doing mining as a business then you treat your mining hardware, electricity costs etc as business costs to be subtracted from your income when figuring your profit. If you buy some BTC at $100 and sell at $150 your profit is $50, as you would expect. Similarly if it costs you $100 to mine bitcoins that you then sell at $150 your profit is also $50.
Re:Tell HN: Meeting Satoshi by JanezStupar on Thursday March 06, 2014 @02:16PM (#7355910)
Yes, you are right.

However he doesn't owe anything as long as he just holds the coins.

Just as you don't owe any taxes on inventory of goods that you have produced from raw materials.