News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by ThomPete on Thursday March 06, 2014 @10:29AM (#7354217)
The press has a lot of knowledge of high interest to the public that they never publish for various reasons.

Sometimes they can't prove a relation, other times they don't feel the public can deal with the information and finally sometimes they are simply asked not to post it.

the primary kind of stories where this is normal is with politicians.

In other words. You argument would have some more weight if it was used everywhere else too.

The press always have a choice and they also did here. It's not in the public interest to figure out who the creator of bitcoin is. It serves no purpose. It ads no value to bitcoin.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by mpyne on Thursday March 06, 2014 @05:02PM (#7356936)
> It's not in the public interest to figure out who the creator of bitcoin is. It serves no purpose. It ads no value to bitcoin.

But it is in Newsweek's interest to find the creator of Bitcoin, if they can get the scoop.

It's the free market plus the Bill of Rights (specifically the First Amendment) in action. A perfectly libertarian thing just happened here, IMHO.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by ThomPete on Thursday March 06, 2014 @05:14PM (#7356989)
You don't live in a libertarian society so that means very little.

The fact is that the press often hold back from releasing information often hold back from using Bill of rights. They should have been more careful here.

Now it's too late. Read below.

http://www.theverge.com/2014/3/6/5479050/press-chases-allege...

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by mpyne on Thursday March 06, 2014 @05:25PM (#7357042)
> You don't live in a libertarian society so that means very little.

Are you saying such a thing would not have happened in a libertarian society? Do you seriously believe that?

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by ThomPete on Thursday March 06, 2014 @05:59PM (#7357182)
I am saying that libertarian or not it has nothing to do with what is being discussed.
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by declan on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:49PM (#7357382)
And the free market plus the Bill of Rights plus tort law could punish Newsweek if they're wrong. See my tweet about legal liability: https://twitter.com/declanm/status/441711365888040960
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by mpyne on Thursday March 06, 2014 @08:57PM (#7358021)
Well, who enforces tort law? The guys with the guns stealing the money from all of us. A government strong enough to suppress the free press is strong enough to oppress the liberties of us all. Etc. etc.

Calling Newsweek 'trash journalism' to shred it of press protections won't do either, as otherwise that would put Wikileaks at risk.

Even if the conclusion of the article is wrong I don't see how you introduce legal liability in the face of the Peter Zenger trial, as long as the facts presented were true (or reasonably believed to be true).

Talking to one's relatives and co-workers is not a crime, after all (and how could it be otherwise; should the government regulate who we can speak to?).

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by ThomPete on Friday March 07, 2014 @12:38PM (#7361547)
You are missing the point.

It doesn't matter how you turn it around. Journalists always have a choice and they constantly keep stuff out of the public.

What matters is not whether they are legally allowed to do these things but whether they should had.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by mpyne on Friday March 07, 2014 @07:03PM (#7363572)
> Journalists always have a choice and they constantly keep stuff out of the public.

Sure. And while I disagree with giving away the guy's address (or information that would lead directly to that), I don't see any other reason why Newsweek shouldn't have tried to track down Bitcoin's creator.

Certainly that's a more compelling story than the normal drivel that hits the media nowadays, so it's hard to argue that Newsweek was filled with higher-value stories that they had to shove aside for this one.

This is an actual attempt at investigative journalism, even if the person they decided to investigate wasn't to your personal liking. Any other news story and people would be claiming "the people have a right to know".

If you take away revealing his personal location (though even that would hardly be difficult to find) I don't see the problem here. The enigmatic Sakamoto was a figure of wide publicity before this story, which is why Newsweek spent money to track to track down his location. And as the creator of a market now worth probably a billion+ (if not more) it's hard to argue that the public has no moral right to investigate more.